I had a cold approaching log in Miami that went for 50+ pages and I did have occasional success with it. To say I have it out for cold approach is just asinine given that I dedicate time to it and still do cold approach. However, it is not out of line to say that cold approach is just not that efficient of a method to meet women if your goal is to get lots of women. Someone with a nice online dating profile will beat your lay count with higher quality women over and over again.
The other thing is that the bar is not that high to get into the top 20% online. In fact, pro photos do set you apart a lot. I am banned from the apps so I had to rely on cold approach.
By all means, I applaud guys who cold approach but having looked at the numbers based on dudes I know, dudes who solely rely on cold approach are not putting up the best results.
Well then the argument becomes quality.
I don't know about you but I don't see a lot of hot girls on the apps, some, but not a lot. Why is that? Because the hot ones don't need it. They snap their fingers and can have a lineup of guys ready to fly them out or wine and dine them with the hope of getting in their pants.
I'm sure there are plenty of guys who beat my lay count, but in my experience, they are unattractive dudes who sleep with whatever woman they can get, regardless of how hot or ugly she is.
I forget where the statistic was mentioned, but women had a tendency to be MORE picky on dating apps and LESS picky in person, while men were generally the opposite. I'm not saying you should exclusively do one or the other, but I hardly think anybody is KILLING IT on dating apps unless they have all their s*** together, are in great shape, young, rich, and have social media to back them up.
When I go up to a hot girl in a bar I have none of those things (well, the great shape part). Yet I still get results. In person it's much easier to punch above your weight, on dating apps you have to settle for being this girl's 2465th backup - if she's even real.
A good anecdote comes down to my last 2 exes I was in serious relationships with:
Tinder - Very hot, much wealthier than me, great sex. BPD, abusive upbringing, created drama, frequent fights, drug problem, very real chance she'll end up alone or with a husband she'll wear the pants in a relationship with. We lasted about 9 months with several very severe fights; notably around Christmas time and Valentine's Day.
Approaching - Also hot, but less hot than the other ex, a little wealthier than me, also great sex. Stable, loving, affectionate, loyal, very sweet, family's a bit of a mess but not nearly as much so as the other ex. Genuinely a great woman, we just didn't end up together because she was ready to settle down and I was not, so I broke up with her so she could meet the husband she's married to now - who she wouldn't have met if she waited for me to change my mind like she originally wanted to do. I met her in an Atlantic City night club, alone, while she was with another hot friend, after having a dude tear my button-down halfway open trying to fight me because I made out with a girl he was interested in earlier in the night. We lasted a little over year, never had a fight.
Both can work, but I run into the latter a lot more often than the former...and like I said, I had a modeling contract...so if I'm not doing great on the dating apps I wonder how much "better" the guys are who do well on them.