I'm a moderator because I believe in the vision of this site.
So do I, that's why I'm here.
I'm not arguing anything, I'm stating my opinion and you're trying to convince me otherwise.
Just assume that if the "Online dating" thread makes no comment about meeting in person, I will close it as said, but If I think its somewhat beneficial I'll keep it open...
How bout just ignore it? Wouldn't that seem to make more sense? Because otherwise, you won't be closing any threads. It's the same as saying, I will only close threads that mention getting laid. If there is no sex involved, then the thread is pointless. So, now unless every question asked directly involves sex, it will be closed. When ultimately every question automatically can be condensed to sex.
Much like every single possible thread dealing with online dating will deal with meeting in person. Regardless of whether you mention it or not. If you're looking for help on your internet profile, it's obviously not because you want to be the coolest guy on your block with your profile. It's because you ultimately want to meet women in real life. I have yet to see a post/question that didn't deal with real women.
Now, if someone asks a question like how do I go in chatrooms and find girls to have cybersex with. Granted, delete away. But, any questions that are legitimately about online dating, should be fine within your rules as far as I understand them. Is that the way I understand it.
Or are you saying that any online dating question that doesn't specifically ask how do I actually transition the girl from online to real life will be closed? Because that's such a small portion of the process, even if the most important process. It would be like IRL DJing, saying only the lay can be discussed. No info on how to get the digits, make the approach, first date techniques, kiss techniques, kino, etc.
Can you see my point?
I think laying out a rationale about what is acceptable and what isn't makes sense. However it's very difficult to have someone who is so obviously prejudiced making the arbitration. It would be like asking a Grand Dragon of the Ku Klux Klan to moderate the NAACP board. Perhaps you have to ask yourself if it makes sense for you to be the moderator of this particular topic. I'd hate to have all the online dating topics moved over to the Mature Man, just because you feel them unfitting for a forum you happen to moderate.
Just my thoughts.
Romeo