Totally respect your anonymity.
In my opinion, 10 emails is not enough. I know it SEEMS like a lot. But that's NOTHING. You gotta spend more time than the average guy--and you gotta be willing to put yourself out there more than the average guy...which means that you gotta email more than the average guy--at LEAST 5 times as many chicks.
Don't be like the average guy and wait for them to come to you. TELL them to meet you!!!
I suggest doing this: Go on match.com and take the time to create a username and a full profile with 6-7 photos. You don't have to pay match.com anything to do that.
Include 1-2 shirtless photos, and try to make that shirtless one of you at the beach or working out.
Then, try to be patient and wait until WED or THURS to subscribe. By then, you'll likely have a handful of incoming messages, even though it'll be anonymous--because you haven't paid to subscribe, you won't be able to to discern who's sent you an email.
It could be a fattie or an ugly or a spammer who's emailing you, but chances are very likely that of the 5 messages, you'll get 1-2 messages from 7's or hotties who want to meet you. BUT--WAIT to respond--even if she's hot. Remember that 99.9999% of guys who join match.com are betas who will respond within an hour or a day of a chick who emails the hot new guy. The DJ who takes his time and seems picky is the one who ultimately succeeds and meets the hottest chicks...so make them WAIT a few days THEN invite them for a drink--on the very first email.
Subscribe for one month only--resist the temptation to subscribe longer...match.com will send you an invite to subscribe at 3 months or 6 months or a year, at a discounted rate. Avoid that. You'll get emails from chicks in the first week or so only--then the messages will stop. So subscribing longer than a month is a total waste of your time and money. Match.com makes money off of guys who are willing to spend more money on 3-month or 6-month subscriptions. Don't fall for it!! Stick to one month only. If you do what I say, you'll have more women than you can physically handle in the next month.
Start by searching and then emailing the hottest 100 chicks that you like--I like to search filter by Newest only. Invite them out for a drink on the very first email: "Dam girl your body is rocking!
I'd like you to meet me for a drink tomorrow night at 7 at the Rusty Nail on 5th and Main in Tampa [be specific]...will you meet me??" They will either say "yes" or "no." The ones who say "no", you can simply ask again in 2-3 weeks, before your subscription ends.
Create the profile now and then, starting WED or THURS of next week, pay to subscribe, and then spend an hour or two each evening hunting down the hottest chicks on match.com., until you have a few that reply--you will then have a few dates lined up for the weekend.