She started asking me about other women and I told her I just have to look out for my 6 ex wives and my 5 juvenile delinquent kids.
Perfect. But you forgot to include the gay lover.
Just kidding. You may have included it for all I know.
Just kidding again. You did well. I think it works to deflect talking about personal matters like that with humor. Especially this early in.
But it does show her doing her reconnaissance work, checking things out. What did she ask specifically?
I called him a loser and she started agreeing with me. She told me he is AFC and he is a "worry wart" and calls her all the time. Poor bastard, he's on the way out. I think she is confused because she said something about not being able to figure me out which is what it's all about right?
Men's interest in a woman is typically so obvious and easy to read, as most guys come on like puppy dogs panting and begging with tongues out, that when a woman encounters mixed signals, she has NO experience reading it, so she's then thrown into a realm that she knows not how to deal with. Very often, they'll simply resort to telling you how they can't read you, you confuse them, and what they're really doing is asking you to please, please tell them if you're interested or not. I think deflecting with humor works here as well: "Honey, you know I can't stand you" with a twinkle in your eye sort of stuff.
Women love not being sure. He loves me. He loves me not. He loves me. He loves me not...
Always better to show by your actions that you're interested rather than in so many words.
I'd still change the subject though. There are no other guys in your universe.
Oh yeah. I don't wanna hear about other men. Me, I wouldn't have shown any negativity and call him a "loser" or anything like that. I'd just be like, "uh huh, uh huh. Ah, another story of sweet love! Hey, I'm hungry, let's grab a bite."
Poor bastard, he's on the way out
Yes it sounds like he is, because, her words are against him. If she were speaking of him badly, but in terms of how it's against her (as in "He never shows me any consideration! We never go out to my favorite places!"), then that may be more about her yearning for a better relationship with the guy.