I'm sorry, but LOOKS are pretty much all of the story, if you don't pass the looks test with a woman, it's game over, and no amount of smooth talking is going to win a woman over. I used to know this Chad (he was 6ft tall, full head of hair, athletic physique), when I went out drinking with him, he always picked up a girl (or should that read, he got PRESELECTED by girls), and he used no game (not that game exists), the women that he went home with him, checked him out, smiled at him, gave him choosing signals and the rest is history.
Most of my 200 odd rejections, in my lifetime, have been body language ones, ie. I didn't have to ask said woman out for her to reject me, I already knew I had been rejected, simply by observing the often hostile,dismissive and combative language eg. the silent treatment, back turns, dirty looks/death stares, one word answers etc.
Ugly looking men rarely attract women, no matter how hard they may try, the only time an ugly looking man gets laid is if he pays a hooker, or he is rich and he is stupid/simpish enough to date/marry a gold digger.