OP's point (see the title of his thread) is that a good body won't get you LAID or equate to MORE S*EX. This is absolutely 100% wrong.
It looks like you failed 1st grade math. I've pointed to numerous examples of very muscular guys who can't get a date at all (unless we're talking borderline 5's and below. Even here, these guys struggle). I've known these guys for years and they can't even get a single date. They've got good careers, middling social skills at least, average-ish facial appearance maybe a bit higher.
To add, what's sad is that several of these muscular guys are actually extroverted and very active in organizing parties, outings and social events. The girls appreciate this, as it saves them all of the effort in meeting good looking guys (not them apparently) and keeps them from looking "desperate" and of course guys like myself don't have to do sh-t and get to hook up with the better looking girls in our groups lol without having to do anything besides show up.
Damn, it's simple Girls 101: Quick lesson -- Women are attracted to healthy men because they represent better offspring. Healthy men have good bodies and yes, good musculature. Accept it and get over it (to the guys whining about it). Bottom line. Done.
Healthy doesn't mean "jacked/ripped." The only reason we see this type at all these days is because of excess hormones in the food supply, steroid abusers and a big push from media to promote 'roided out freaks as role models. I'm sorry you were dumb enough to take the bait.
As far as evolution, it favors having a higher percentage of body fat as we have lived through feast and famine periods for 99.9% of our species' history. It's not like Wal Marts were everywhere 10,000 years ago. You're being ridiculously short sighted and don't have the faintest clue as to what you're talking about.
Look at the celebrity guys women swoon over. ALL are lean and fit and some have good musculature. None are fat assess, frumpy, or slobs.
It's not women who swoon over 'roid monkeys like Dwayne Johnson, it's guys like you who are swooning over them LMAO.
Dwayne Johnson's ex is a borderline 5 at best.
The guys women actually do swoon over: Leo DiCaprio, Johnny Depp, etc, are skinny AF. Chris Hemsworth is muscular but he'd still have female fans if he were much thinner as he has a good looking face.
Not to poke sticks at OP, but he admitted he was 40# overweight at one time. It doesn't sound to me like he's a guy who places a lot of emphasis on his health and now he's p*issed and looking for excuses as to why he doesn't get laid more.
I'm still 5 to 10 pounds above what I would consider to be my ideal weight. The reality is, it's made literally zero difference in my ability to date and attract women.
Sorry you've wasted all of your time in the gym all of these years (decades?). It makes no difference. You just wasted a sh-t ton of your life grunting like a stuck pig in a room with dozens of smelly men and downing disgusting soy protein shakes. What a waste lol.
The reality is, you're throwing a tantrum just like a woman, which is all too common for steroid abusers.