thing is, Chad = guy she's attracted to.
to these girls u were their Chad
Joe Normal in this instance = guy she's not attracted to.
so of course, 'guy she's not attracted to' will creep her out.
If she's not attracted to (or sexually available to) the guy you normally think of as Chad (6'3 traditionally good looking white guy) then HE is Joe Normal to her (which might be completely outside of your reality if you've never been in the same venue as someone that fits that description, get shut down and instead rely on incel youtube videos as your reference material).
Pretty sure i'm with Velasco on this (If I understood correctly)
I'm the most redpilled fukker there is when it comes to looks having digested years of PUA stuff and also gamed with some really handsome dudes. I feel like I speak from good experience and i've believed both sides of the coin at one point, but settled where I have - I'm WELL aware that it (attraction) is basically all about looks.
Having said that, i'm also aware that girls really do have differring tastes (a bit like that twitter post quoted above)
I used to work with lots of girls in an office and they spend all day browing insta and checking out various hot guys etc. Even sometimes Dming' them (something PUA's claim would never happen lol)
However, one of the girls (actually the hottest one) would always pick guys that the other girls weren't into ''You like HIM!!!??? He looks old and skinny!!'' or whatever.
It's partly why I got a bit disilusioned about game at one point and realised that the only true 'game' was in fact 'numbers game!'. E.g - you have zero influence or control when you are gaming. And almost anything will work if she's physically attracted and nothing will work if she's not. And it also explained why someone like Tyler could occassionally pull a hot girl. He got rejected a tonne (and admitted it!) but when he pulled a hot girl, youtube was like 'See what game can Do!!!? Looks don't matter!! etc. But due to what I said above, I know that it was likely a case of that girl just thinking he was kinda cute. Believe it or not, some girls think skinny ginger guys with blue eyes and beards are hot (I know he's a fatass now but whatever)
I'm not good looking, but i've had a few fukking lottery wins at this point and pulled girls that my friends kinda teased me about i.e - 'How the hell did YOU pull her!!!??? She's half your age you ugly old b@astard!'' (us brits are kinda mean to our mates lol)
But I wasn't pattig myself on the back or credtied my NLP verbals and embedded comands. It was because I stumbled upon a cute girl, way too young and hot for me, who happened to like how I look! She was attracted (and I bet NONE of her friends were lol). And I had enough 'game' to not completely **** it up (because that's honestly what i've come to realise 'game' is lol)