When I say above par it means it's a confluence of traits within masculinity.Not necessarily. You're falling into a potential trap when you think "I did x,y,z, therefore, I should attract women."
This is the fundamental difference of opinion in this thread.
I agree 100% that a man should follow his own path, on his own terms, and not be a slave to the feminine imperative.
But I don't conflate the feminine imperative with the fact that a man still has to approach and seduce females. Having stripes on your sleeve will get you some attention, but pursuing your life's goals and then waiting for the pu$$y to roll in isn't a plan for getting what you want. In other words, be your own man, but take action with women just as you do with career, lifestyle, hobbies, self-improvement, etc.
I don't often cite Rollo, but he put it well (if a bit straw-man-ish - and no I'm not calling you "haters"):
16. Dancing Monkey Hate
Hater: Men who run game are just doing the bidding of women. Alphas don’t entertain women.
If you want success with women, you are going to have to entertain them… one way or the other...We are all doing the bidding of our biomechanical overlord, and on our knees to his will we surrender, by force or by choice. You fool yourself if you believe you have some plenary indulgence from this stark reality.
Or: If you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em.
I don't think this subject is binary. Both sides can be right. Women will CERTAINLY auto-tune themselves to their feminine level around a masculine, attractive man. But it's a harsh biological reality that women are the gatekeepers of sex. This is not the "feminine imperative," it's an evolutionary fact whether you like it or not. Your ability to make her vagina tingle is the proof in the pudding (gross metaphor but you get what I mean). Whether that happened through your social dominance, income level, notoriety, etc. or just the way you looked her in the eye and what you said, or some combination thereof. She might make it all kinds of easy for you, but you as a man still have to navigate the shoals, and a lot of otherwise-masculine men are ignorant about how to do this. And some of us with plenty of knowledge and experience still mess it up sometimes. That's why this site exists.
This is why I singled out the "all our ancestors procreated" point earlier. It always has something to do with women, as all the posts in this thread prove.
Does it guarantee women will spread their legs?
No.
But it is more then likely, the probability will be higher that he attracts women to his side in all settings because like you said its biological.
Women on a deep level are more attracted to masculine man. For example, if you display a big muscled body but scream like a girl when a rat passes by or cries like baby when u r emotionally hurt then attraction will automatically be muted.
As for Rollo, his worldview is from an expressive/passive - through his own experiences or through his own lens.
For him entertaining women's whims and fancies might be the order of the day.
And for many here, game is a step by step process of being a seducer.
But for me, game is just frame, my sum total, and its women who seduces me which is basically the only thing I know.
You hardly see me posting a step by step ritual because I truly don't know how, maybe a little, maybe subconsciously but it all comes from a confluence of masculine traits.
I most certainly don't go out looking pretty, nor the need for certain hairsprays nor a certain type of dressing nor use tricks that in all actuality to me is just preying on women's insecurities.