Actually, I'm running into the same problem myself. As I explained, I'm done with the superfical girls who only offer me a hormonal rush. I want a girl who has more to offer, someone with values, great personality, who I can have a stable relationship with. At the same time, I notice it's hard to find such a girl who ALSO has high sex appeal and is pretty.
But there's one in my social circle who kinda fits that image. She always seems interested in me but I used to disregard her because she is not that sexy, she wears unattractive clothes (not ugly clothes but just clothes that don't accentuate her curves etc. Clothes that you would wear if you DO NOT want guys' attention, doesn't use much make-up, acts kinda controlled and business-like instead of flirty. In fact, she has a pretty face and her body is okay. I guess face 7.5/8 and body 7. But the way she presents herself, both in looks as in behavior, is just very bland. She acts like a robot, lol, there's just no excitement.
At the same time, she's very sweet, kinda shy, seems like someone with good moral values, wants to make the world a better place, has a good heart, very decent, very kind, someone who's honest. I think she'd be a great girlfriend in that regard, I rate her very highly regarding her personality traits. But yeah, very low sex appeal. It's more like I'd choose her as my girlfriend because my rational brain tells me she is a suitable partner, rather than my body/hormonal system/instinct telling me I feel attracted to her and want to kiss her have sex with her etc.
However, I recently saw her wearing some tight jeans and heels, wearing a bit more make-up etc. And she actually did look kinda hot! So I've been thinking about her lately and actually have been trying to convince myself that I should pursue her.
So I ran into her last week and took a good look at her from a distance, lol. She was looking good and I told myself "Dude, she might actually be what you want. She's been in front of you all this time you've known her but you always looked past her because she's so bland. But honestly, look at her, she's quite nice man! And she has those personality traits that you so desperately wish for in a woman!"
And then I turned beta................. It's so fvcking ironic! I kinda realized that she might come close to the unicorn that we're all looking for. The rare quality girl among all the worthless garbage girls. And it turned me into a beta.... I've never been nervous around her before, in fact I always kinda felt sorry for her when she showed signs of interest and I didn't reciprocate, lol. I always perceived her as uninteresting and therefor acted totally confident towards her, whereas she was often acting a little insecure towards me.
But now it was totally different, I was nervous and acted a bit insecure. In fact, there were some moments where it seems like she found me unattractive, the way women see "nice guys" as unattractive and put them in the friendzone...
Basically, I kinda messed up the whole interaction. Was thinking about making a move, like asking her number or whatever. But I got fearful of rejection and it made me hesitate. It was kinda cringeworthy.... I feel like I failed and am totally ashamed of myself... What a fiasco! I almost felt like 14 year old me who had a crush on a girl in high school and didn't dare speak to her! WTF?!?!?!
This was very confronting. I handle hot chicks confidently all the time, but now I turn into a beta with this one. It's exactly because I see her as potential girlfriend material... She actually might have something to offer besides superficial pleasure. And that means she's rare, that she might present a rare chance, which means there's actually something at stake when I try to get her. And that causes outcome dependancy and nervousness when I interact with her. Whereas there was none of that before!! But yeah, now I consider her almost as if she's the solution to this strong displeasement with women that's been constantly bugging me for a while now. Which puts her on a pedestal and ruins everything anyway.... So I guess I do need to work on myself first, the feeling of displeasement comes from a deep desire to experience a healthy stable relationship, which find its roots in a very disturbed relationship with my parents as a child. So I guess I got to go back to the core.....
Anyway, my point is that I kind of encounter the same issue I talked about in the beginning of this post. When you meet someone who seems to have it all, you become insecure, to the point of self-sabotage. I've dated or had relationships with a lot of crappy women (personality wise), most of them had low self esteem and were total drama queens. I've almost never dated an emotionally healthy girl with good moral values, high self esteem etc. Why? Because deep down I'm afraid of them.... Deep down I feel I'm not good enough for them, that I don't deserve them, that I don't have what it takes to make them consider me as their boyfriend (which is exactly what many women experience when they encounter a really great guy and makes them choose a less perfect guy, if you ask me).
I think that's also why I feel aversion to being the sex guy. I've had plenty of encounters where I knew girls wanted to fvck me, but only just that, fvck me.... Some had a boyfriend, some just wanted no relationship with anyone, whatever. And I've capitalized on the opportunity sometimes, but it always left me with a negative feeling. Why does she only want to fvck me? Am I not good enough to be her boyfriend? It messes with my self esteem, basically. In a way, I want to feel validated by knowing that a girl is interested in a relationship with me. If she's not interested in that, I feel there's something "wrong" with me, as if I'm not good enough for her to consider me as a boyfriend. Yeah I know, never look for validation, that's beta and puts you in a weak position, plus she'll see that and lose attraction for you blahblah. But I can tell myself 100 times that I don't need that validation, in the meantime I still feel like I need it deep down inside. I can supress that need and forcefully ignore it to the point that I'm not aware of it anymore, but it's still there at my core, in my subconcsious. And the subconscious has a way of sabotaging you from within when it feels you are ignoring it....
And in fact, there IS something wrong with me that makes me not good enough to be considered as her boyfriend.... I do have issues and would say I'm emotionally unhealthy. I've been emotionally abused as a child and it has left scars and makes me less capable of forming healthy emotional attachments to women. I attract emotionally damaged girls like honey attracts bees, because they and me are alike.
No "good" girl, who had a warm loving family and healthy emotional relationship to her parents, will be attracted to me. Deep down, I know this and I fear it when I meet such a girl, like the one I mentioned earlier. I feel that she's too good for me, that I don't have what it takes to obtain her (or once obtained, to keep her).... So I tend to choose (largely unconsciously) "easier" targets. Girls with low self esteem, who are emotionally damaged, act irresponsible, need to be corrected like little children all the time (but never change their behavior anyway, lol). They're trash.... But maybe I deserve no better, because I'm trash myself....