The Tommi Lee Syndrome
The difficulty most guys have with accepting that women will generally opt for Bad Boys in favor of Nice guys is that their behaviors always betray their words. Think about it this way; like most guys we prefer simple, rudimentary answers to solve problems. Car wont move, I put gas in car, car moves, goal achieved. Likewise, with women we want a simple solution - I need sex, women withhold sex, ask women "what do you want from a guy" to achieve sex, modify behavior accordingly to get sex, goal achieved. Simple deductive reasoning.
Yet the problem occurs that this isn't the method that produces semi-predictable, reliable results, because women have confounding variables in what they 'think' it takes for them to become intimate. Ask a woman why she continues to keep resuming an abusive relationship or has sex with her outlaw biker after complaining about 'how he is' and they'll say they don't know or "I guess I'm just a sucker for the Bad Boy." They may genuinely not recognize the psycho-biological reasons for their own behaviors. And it is women's behavior and the modifying circumstances and environments that we need to pay attention to in order to get what we want. Bad Boy gets the results I want (i.e. unlimited access to unlimited sexuality), what are Bad Boy's behaviors and characteristics that produce these results? He rides a motorcycle (external behavior), he is extroverted (external trait), hell, just look at all the examples from the initial post of this thread - each defining characteristic of the Bad Boy makes him the object to be sought, he is the PRIZE.
Look at the tumultuous relationship between Tommi Lee and Pamela Anderson. We have Pam as (arguably) one of the most desirable women on planet earth. She is a genetic celebrity and I can't think of a single guy I know who wouldn't want to get after it with her. Next we have Tommi, Bad Boy, rock star, has had more tail in a single year than most of us will get in a lifetime. He is a sought after commodity in the sexual marketplace. We have two highly in demand persons in this couple. Tommi is with a girl guys dream of and Pam is with a Bad Boy that women will stand in line to get with. They get married and Tommi's abusive nature surfaces. Tommi gets arrested for domestic abuse and gets a warning. Pam takes him back. 6 months later Tommi again abuses the most desirable woman in the world and is arrested this time. Pam wont press charges. A year later same behavior, Tommi beats up Pam and goes to jail for 8 months. Pam's response? "I still love him and I wish things could be better between us." Pam files for divorces and a year later is in an LTR with Kid Rcok.
Behavior, behavior, behavior. It is not what a woman says, it is what she does! Women are biologically attracted to men who display these qualities and consequently she wants to breed with him. The Nice guy is a good choice for the responsibilities of parental investment in raising offspring, but is rarely the one who's genetic material she wants to pass on. There are men women want to fvck and men they want to marry. Rarely do the two exist in the same person. That's the challenge, to simultaneously display the physical traits that she finds desirable in the Bad Boy (the guys she wants to fvck) and be the provider of the security she desires in a mate and use this to your advantage.
The Bad Boy dynamic is the reason women want to fvck the powerful corporate exec and the drug dealer in the ghetto. Both posess the dynamic, just in different arenas.
As SAPHIRE stated, since women tend to lose their sexual value as they age, there come a stage in their lives when they will rearrange their priorities for their intimacy. Women would like you to believe that this decision represents a new degree of maturity for them when actually it become their only recourse to get to long term security that men provide. A 22 y.o. woman's conditions for intimacy may be the Bad Boy that gets her hot, but as she reaches 28-29 she understands that he can't provide for her long term security and then searches out the Nice Guy who does have the means. Sappy, blissfully ignorant, Nice Guy thinks he's finally hit the jackpot after all these years and gives her exactly what she's planned for. It works out even better if she's a single mommie, pregnant by the Bad Boy (who's moved on to equally fertile females) and Nice Guy is willing to play the role of saviour. Finding a male who will securely share the parental investment for the offspring of a more genetically desirable male's (irregardless of the method) is an evolutionary gold mine for the female of any species.