Update for Aaron: I just had several girls compliment me on my niceness over the last few days. Some I knew for a while; some I just met. Here's how the situations went down, and this is very common:
Took 1 girl to the hospital because she was crazy sick. I sat by her as she was almost passed out on the couch, and bought her some water. She said I am the one of the nicest guys she ever knew. I kind of argued the point, because I'm really not. But she disagreed and said I was. She hugged me, said I was a sexy *****, she likes [my type], and was down for dating if I was up for it.
Drove with girl 2 to see her family. We were talking about past relationships, and I mentioned that I like to learn more about the person before having sex. She didn't fail safe driving, so I took over. She said I'm cute and very sweet, then poked me, grabbed my ass, and flirted like crazy. I had to turn her down for personal reasons, but she said any girl would be lucky to have me, I'd make a terrific boyfriend, and she was very disappointed in the rejection.
Listened to girl 3 complain about her problems, and gave her advice - like you're not supposed to do. Sometimes I like to go against the grain for the hell of it, and see what happens. She got super excited, couldn't believe I was there for her, said I was attractive and sweet, and too good to be true. The conversation quickly turned sexual on her part. I mentioned how I used to take hour-long showers, and she said we will have to do that together soon. There was a lot more... This girl was super horny. She also talked about wanting a relationship and how we should go to Florida so she can cook me the shrimp I love so much. She got a little too excited, but whatever.
Was driving girl 4 home after work, and asked her if she wanted something to eat. We were talking prior to that, and she said I was very sweet, caring and attentive. She wanted to "ravage" me in the car, and come over to have sex on my bed. Then talked about her fantasies, which were... Yeah. They say weird, random things when they're in the moment.
Was playing basketball outside - when I said "hi" to girl 5. Just acknowledging her presence; she was on the way other side of the court. She came over to play with me, I offered her water, and was "nice" as we were playing together. Asked about herself, offered her to rest when she seemed tired, etc. She had the biggest smile on her face the whole time. You don't guard people the way she was with me. She played with my necklace, couldn't stop smiling, and asked for my number.
Girl 6 I've known for a while. She was complaining about her ******* exes. I'm not sure how it happened, but she said she has nothing against dating a friend. I think its because I mentioned that girls don't do that, and its not a good idea, or something to that effect. Then she said I was sexified, a pretty boy, always there for her, and once again turning the conversation sexual.
I have so many stories like this. It happens on a near-daily basis. The same stuff all these nice guys do - so do I. I don't do anything but act nice. Don't even flirt or turn the conversations sexual - they do that, and I just follow. I don't charm these girls, or act like a douche bag. Just being normal and nice.
The only difference is, these girls are attracted. They tell me the same things, and give me the same lines as these other guys... But they want sex and relationships. It comes down to sexual attraction. There's nothing more to it. These are all good-looking girls, because I don't really hang out with ugly ones too much.