wow, 3 pages of posts and from a quick scan i dont think any of you have hit the nail on the head.
it is NOT about whether her requests were fair or unfair. depending on how you look at them they could be either.
the things she's asking for aren't unreasonable, its the fact that she's asking for them thats unreasonable.
the MAJOR red flag here is that drmeathead is being totally upfront and honest with this chic, and instead of her saying 'you know, thank you for being honest. we aren't looking for the same things so we might as well go our seperate ways.' she's saying 'well, that won't do. let me tell you what i expect. blah blah blah. oh, and i dont sleep with anyone who doesn't do those things.'
she has every right to set whatever expectations of a man she wants onto a person she is dating. what she does NOT have the right to do is to try and use her p*ssy to impose conditions on the relationship and get him to behave in a way that he has no desire to behave in.
so the problem isn't in her wanting these things, the problem is in her wanting them from drmeathead who has said he has no interest in giving them to her and using her p*ssy power to try and get him to act like a 'decent' guy (decent by her subjective standards that is).
the folks calling drmeat a caveman are off i think. He has been 100% honest and up front with this woman. you literally cannot do anything more than that.
and you know, i wouldn't have an issue with her if she were simply laying out her views 'i like guys who like x,y, and z.' that would be the same as what drmeat did, just being honest up front. but when you throw in 'and i dont sleep with guys who blah blah blah' - whoooo nelly, that is 100% clear p*ssy power manipulation in play.
drmeat was right to cut loose of this woman.