OP needs to remove the "social circle" component from his description. Looks and height are probably the least important factors. In fact outside of some club environments and OLD more generally social dominance is everything and largely a result social skills / status.
But maybe it depends on your circle. Amongst my friends the general consensus is that women stop caring about looks once they graduate high school. In the real world money and status (power) are far more important. The man at the top of any dominance hierarchy will never lack for women no matter how physically unattractive he may be.
My friends are doctors, lawyers, software developers, bankers, surveyors, etc. and many of us associate with big money men (e.g. premier league footballers) so it's fair to say we have seen it all.
I can see why if you spent half of your day as a club bouncer, as OP does you might have a more skewed perspective.
Raw attraction is status , looks, money in that order.
But enough money can more or less guarantee you the first and help tremendously with the second.