Ace of Flames said:
I don't suggest DOING NOTHING. I suggest NOTHING IS NECESSARY. Sex isn't part of a kid's life, and it shouldn't be. They don't need it.
Obviously they don't need it when they're little. I think globally, if done properly (which again is very, very difficult), it benefits kids in the long run to know how to properly understand sex, in preparation for the feelings they will have at age 12. Keep in mind the usual "problem" of adolescence. In child welfare you see this all the time. Adopted kids are super sweet until age 11 and then they're a huge behavior problem. Research is showing more and more that talking openly about sex is one great way of defusing the bomb. Let's face it, kids need to be more ready for it.
More and more psychologists are agreeing, also, that adolescence is a difficult time of transition, but REALLY doesn't have to the hell it is in most kids with proper parenting. Talking openly about sex, especially in today's media culture, and with the type of internet access kids have, is more and more important.
I think kids would develop in a more healthy way if they found out about sex earlier. And not from Brittany Spears.
So I know what you're thinking, "yeahh, just sit the kid down in front of porn, that will work great." Well, I don't think your inability, off the top of your head, to think of a way to explain this, disproves anything.
From the beginning I've been agreeing with you (and you keep claiming we disagree I don't know why) that is is fvcking hard to explain this in a beneficial way to a child. So you can name all sorts of halfass ways to expain it and you still won't be disagreeing at all.
I have a sister. She's turning 7 this weekend. If my mom and I sat her down and tried to seriously explain sex to her, she'd giggle at the funny words, she wouldn't understand the majority of what we're saying to her, and the concepts she DID get some grasp of, she'd go to school and tell her friends about it. The teacher would overhear, and the next thing you know we'd get a call at home saying we should seek family counseling or something. They'd claim we have an unfit home environment or some sh!t.
That's kind of the rub about telling the truth. Most parents want their kids living in fantasy land. It's the same with Santa Claus... all parents hate the kid who tells everyone Santa doesn't exist since age 2. And some parents are so ashamed of their own sexuality, and their own sexual thoughts and feelings, that a kid who knows that sex exists is a threat to them.
Bonhomme put it best: "A parent's task is to convey the idea that sex is a good thing, but only when people are truly ready to deal with its consequences."
Now, my sister is pretty smart for a (soon to be) 7 year old. She speaks more like a 13 year old would, with complicated sentence structure and a fairly wide vocabulary. I believe she'd still be just as confused and mixed up with all the information about sex we'd tell her as any other 7 year old. They just aren't ready to take in this kind of thing. They aren't at the point in their lives where the information is even RELEVANT, so I don't see why giving them extra worries and unneeded confusion is helping anything.
What you're saying is pretty vague. How am I supposed to agree or disagree that your sister wouldn't react well to what you said, if you're not telling me what you'd tell her?
I don't have much I can say to that, except that whatever you have in mind, you're probably right that you have the wrong approach.
Maybe you don't know kids as well as you think. I know that kids are impressionable. They see stuff on TV, they wanna try it. They imitate things. If you gave some kids a big talk about sex, and then locked them in a room for a few hours, you'd be sure to find that all the kids will be taking their pants off, comparing their bits and pieces, and then they'd sure as hell wanna try out what they just 'learned'.
It depends what you say and how you say it. Most kids I know, if you tell them what Bonhomme said, they'll be just fine:
"A parent's task is to convey the idea that sex is a good thing, but only when people are truly ready to deal with its consequences."
You tell kids that some day if they're not careful when they're trying to make babies, they can get sick, or have to care for a baby rather than getting a job, they will get the idea. You can tell kids when you get older you might want to make babies too.
There are plenty of children's books out there written by psychologists that explain sex to kids. This is not a new idea.
I think the number one thing you want to avoid with kids is keeping sex a secret. I'm not saying sit them down in front of porn, because porn does not represent a proper understanding of what sex is and should be. Notice how porn actors, even in the throes of ecstasy don't joke or laugh or just stop and stare at each others' eyes like lovers do. It's all business.
Most people are so love-deprived, so terrified of love that their understanding of sex is like porn. And of course THAT understanding is harmful to kids. It's harmful to everybody. That's the whole problem.
Sex isn't dirty when you properly understand it. There is nothing shameful or worthy of a secret if you have the right attitude about sex. You're right that you do have to package it a certain way with kids, and yes some details get left out of that packaging. That's normal. That's not to say that you can't be honest to the extent that a kid can understand.
And absolutely, kids will talk about what they know. Most of the time, though, when something is beyond a kid's understanding, he doesn't even think about it. Like I play with my four year old neighbors, I say something they don't understand, and they run and show me a pony. It's hilarious.
After all, you just told them that when a man and a woman like each other, they have sex, right?
No, that's not what I'd say. More evidence that you haven't thought of the right way to express it yet.
Besides, that's not even true. Lots of boys and girls like each other and don't have sex. I DO IT ALL THE TIME (side topic
)
Well little boys and little girls are friends, and they'll misunderstand your explanation about as fast as a lightning bolt. You would walk back into that room with lots of little kids laying on top of each other trying to have sex. Is that what you want? Cuz I'll bet you anything that's what would happen.
No, it's not what I want and I'll bet you anything it wouldn't happen. It would if you used your explanation though. *punches playfully on the arm*
Also, I really like how you just say "Good luck" to the thought of preventing kids' access to media with sex and such. That's one hell of an attitude. I figured someone with your innovative way of thinking would be all for that. You thought of this whole way to preempt the media, when you should really be thinking of a way to shut it down. You remind me of the idiotic concept called "Preemptive War". There's no such thing. Its just who hits who first.
Shut it down? LOL, it's a free country. Yeah, I wouldn't let my kids watch just anything. On the other hand, let's be realistic on the one hand that I can't supervise kids 24 hours a day. And they're curious little buggers. They should be curious. Things happen, and if you've already told a kid about the proper way to understand sex, they'll realize it's a hugely dangerous thing that takes a lot of knowledge and responsibility.
You do make a good point, though, that most parents don't know how to have an open relationship with their kid. You've got a point that to talk about sex, it does take an open and non-shaming relationship with a kid. That's a safety valve is just having the type of relationship with your kid where the kid can be honest with you. That's the whole point of telling the kid early, so that it's something you talk about with your parents.
Secondly, this media is fed by people who have major hang-ups about sex. I do love me some porn, but the more I learn about sex the more I realize that porn is just really boring to me. Where's the love? The happier and more love-filled I am, the less I need the nonsense in the media. There's no need to control it because if you raise a kid properly, they won't even be interested in what is trash. It is the love-starved who congregate to nonsense, and even worse, who act upon it.
Third, if you prepare a kid for what's in the media, I don't think it will really have much of an effect.
Honestly, its not that damn hard to keep your kids away from sexual stuff, at least in your own home.
Note the key words, "at least in your own home."
If people knew how to be fvcking good parents, lots of these problems wouldn't be so big. But no, they watch R-rated movies and explicit TV shows, and just let their kids sit there with them. They take their babies to the theater to see murder dramas and sexual comedies and horror movies.
I don't think any of those behaviors would be half as serious if people actually knew how to be good parents as you say.
This is a very interesting discussion, and a pleasure.