Lol, lol, lol, guys listen
Nobody's right and nobody's wrong.
Women view the world totally different than how we do, how they view "hot" is different, how they rate a guy as "good-looking" is different.
We are logical, a pretty face, nice body= good looking.
Women are emotional, if she feels a certain "feel" when looking at him and being around him, he becomes = hot, good looking.
She is posting based on how women view the world, not based on how we view it. That's why your mother and sister would say about the same thing, because that's how women view the world.
We are attracted to women beginning with the matter, or the body, then we go into how smart, cool, and how great of a personality she has.
Women are attracted first to the guy's beliefs, which determine is she gets this "feel" when being around him, which makes her want him. Then she goes into trying to change him if he is a jerk, into being smart, ambitious, nicer, etc.
Guys open your minds and read more.