But this is what im saying, you've had success without having to be funny, which means your a good looking guy who is trying to hard, its no different than this guy at my gym, he has these massive arms and is jacked, 7'5 tall and walks around the gym because he's already maxxed out so what is he doing at the gym? He's totally available and it's disgusting to women, I wish I could take a picture of this guy to show you all, I watched him struggle to have a conversation with a child, it was embarrassing.
So your right, you shouldn't do the Humor thing, but if your gonna avoid playing into your weaknesses, why not steer playing into your strengths, get some pictures done, take some time with it, even better do a video if your not photogenic.