Mauser96 said:
This is what I stated - which you then went on to disagree with
Mauser96 said:
You have lost some power.
Mauser96 said:
If you move out and THEN she contacts you? Well, you have all your power back now.
I am disagreeing with you, but that is not what you stated. You said he lost "some power". He never had any power to begin with moving into her place. Then you claimed he will get all of his power back when he moves out and she contacts him. How can he get back "power" he never had? That is what you are claiming and I'm disagreeing with.
Mauser96 said:
I posted this, but didn't spell it out. I assumed everyone would know. When you move in, it definitely decreases your power- she knows your whereabouts 24/7, and you can't get distance or create mystery.
No, you did not post that or even come close to verbalizing those sentiments. All you said was he lost "some power", talk it over with her, if he moves out and she contacts him he will regain his "power".
Moving in only decreases your power if you move into her place as an occupant. If you move her into your place, you own the place, and can run it anyway you like on your terms. So, do you believe men who live with women at the man's place has decreased power?
Mauser96 said:
Agreed. But if she wants to make it work, the talk I suggested may work. If she doesn't, nothing will work, why stay and be miserable.
Communication is important with every relationship. Moving out over something small or something that can be easily worked out is irresponsible. We don't even know what the quarrel was over since he refuses to provide us the details.
Mauser96 said:
You just disagreed with yourself. Earlier , above you said he lost his power when he moved in. Thus, he regains it when he moves out. He should have the talk. If it can't be resolved, move out.
I've never disagreed with myself. Where are you getting that from? You're disagreeing with the new claims you're making from what you originally said before.
He had no power when he moved in, and he will have no power he moves out. You're claiming he will gain power when he moves out. How can he regain power he never even had? You're saying that he will gain power, that's the claim you're making here.
Mauser96 said:
He is already IN her place!and then leaving with her using it against him.Not sure what you mean here.
Why aren't you sure? Don't you know your own advice you're giving this guy?
If he moves out, he is no longer in her place, is he? He was concerned that if he moves out, that will destroy the relationship. That's why he wrote this thread looking for advice. Aren't you following what's going on? When he moves out, she can use his actions of moving out, to use against him for her not wanting to salvage the relationship.
Mauser96 said:
The bottom line is, have a chat. If it can't be resolved, he needs to decide whether to leave.
Decide whether to leave? If it can't be resolved, he should leave, that is the whole point. Why would you still stay at a woman's place when an issue can't be resolved? She would probably make him leave if that was the case.
That isn't what we are discussing here. He wanted to know if he moves out if it would ruin the relationship. Moving out would ruin the relationship. That's why he needs to see if it can be worked out. If it can't, he needs to move out, and expect to have this relationship ended for good.