Even 1's are getting more messages than most guys will get on POF (this is because guys will chase the top girls when they first get on; realize most of them are only going for the top guys, and slowly degrade their standards to the point they're hitting on women they'd never give a second glance to in public.) It's just the way things are setup there.
POF is 80% pics, 20% content of your words. That's the reality of this game.
Women saying "you're being rude" is a result of them not being attracted to you. Create a profile with a generic hot guy and say the same thing to them and I'd bet $100 they are more receptive.
What your pics tell me is you're a goof ball (the 3rd pic with the girl pulling on the back of your neck is HORRIBLE dude). That's not the image you want to present on a dating site (At least not if you want to sexually attract women.) I know you're trying to be the whole "cool nerd" thing; to appear outgoing... But unless you find the perfect girl who is looking for just that - you're going to have 0 success as is.
Let's take a look at the profile:
I’m all about making myself better, I’m not a self improvement freak, but well yes I AM a self improvement freak. Deal with it. I like it how I feel about my life and that my life gets better every day.
This is pretty bad. The "Deal with it" seems completely rude and out of place. Why would one have to "Deal with" you liking self improvement? Is there an anti-self improvement movement among women where you live?
This profile would be more entertaining if you said "I like to snort coke off the ass of strippers. Deal with it!" ... I'm not even kidding...
I have a confection to make, I’m such a typical sports fan that i get out my jersey and hold the ball in my lap, if we wind up together please schedule spa visits, shoe shopping, or male bashing with girlfriends during important sorting events, it will make both of our life’s better.
I'm not even sure what you're trying to do here. You're lost and it's obvious; you don't even know what to put here. You're not putting any emotion into this; it's all just "this - that - this - that - this"... It's just hollow words...
if you want to know more just shoot me a message. i'll reply if i got the time.
Complete and total uncalibrated arrogance. This.... is why sosuave can fvck people up. You're presenting what you believe you should and it's not authentic.
Women.... Can overlook such things if the guy has a look to make up for it...
something low key, 12 course dinner with 14 deserts with someone sinning love songs in the background. you know. LOW KEY.
LEGIT GIRLS: over the top and ridiculous,playfulness In nature, quiet and loud, sexy plus gorgeous, has to be girlie,Funny t-shirt wearing, Knows when to Hold 'em and Fold 'em, sits in coffee shops All day, 4am breakfast, knows how to cook, Spontaneous combustion, has a sense of style, Meet the Press VS the colbert report. Nerds can have fun too, has to be a big Hugger, knows how to make a drink, Free loving, knows how to shop, Pants droppin, Earth shock, Arm Rockin, booty shakin, love makin, History makin, LEGENDARY GIRL!
This isn't horrible. Although your list of demands goes on a bit long... I'd cut it down to a few of the best stuff... Which is pretty much everything you wrote before "knows how to cook"...
Overall: I know nothing about you from your profile other than that you seem like you're confused. And that your ****iness does not match the way you look in your pictures.
3 things:
1) Get better pictures. I don't care if you have to take 1000 pictures - if you want success online - you need 2-3 good pictures. If this requires working on your style, body, etc - there's nothing wrong with that.... You do like self-improvement afterall. (without this - 2 & 3 will not matter)
2) Rewrite your profile and engage the reader with something interesting. Evoke emotions....
3) Stop sending a message that looks the same as 90% of the other people. When sending a message to a woman on there - engage her.
That's it.