New Girlfriend - Trustworthy or not? Opinions needed!

ApolloCreed

Don Juan
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
30
Reaction score
1
Started dating a chick mid January (my first posts on here referred to this specific girl), and I'm trying to assess her value level. First exclusive relationship in 5 years, but I've got a lot of experience with dating, so when I spot red flags I don't forget them easily.

Ok, a bit about her/us: she's attractive, intelligent, with a very good career. She pushed for exclusivity, then eventually recently asked me to be her boyfriend. We currently spend around 4 nights a week together, and she goes all out for me in terms of both the bedroom and doing unexpected sweet things/buying me ****/inviting me places with her friends (who I've overheard talking very favourably about me). FYI, she's admitted to cheating in past relationships, as have I.

Now, before I explain some points of interest I must disclose that I'm secretly suspicious and skeptical with pretty much every girl I date, mainly due to a long history of cheating and being cheated on. I keep this aspect of my personality hidden, so this new girlfriend likely has almost zero idea I'm having doubts.


Red Flags/stuff I've noticed:

- Initially played a good girl routine until I told her to drop the act. I'm no saint and far from naive.

- Spotted inconsistencies and lies about past dating history (including only recently finding out she was 'casually seeing' someone at the time we met). I know this is something girls often do and not necessarily indicative, but it makes you wonder.

- Lives in a mixed sex share house, with one of the guys acting strange and almost hostile towards me.

- Was meant to be meeting me and friends for dinner on the 2nd day of starting a new job. Text me saying she'd be late due to a meeting at 5pm. Asked her how it went around 7.30pm and she gave a weird, avoidant response. Saw a couple of call logs and a text between her and a guy on that day saying "en-route now, meet at >company HQ< at 4pm". Her job involves a lot of coordinating people, and this guy may well innocently be a team member or her boss, but who knows.

- Her and her friend came to a party being hosted by some dude I know (friend of a friend). Her friend was sick, so she took her upstairs to lay down. This guy followed them upstairs after 5 mins, and was gone for maybe 20-30 mins. Didn't think anything of it, until a couple of hours later he was asking me if I'm with "that girl". As we left his house, my girlfriend told him she'd "send him those contacts" (we were all briefly talking about work at one point, but there was no swapping of numbers). The next day I casually asked if she sent this guy the contacts, and she said she doesn't have his contact details, which seemed odd considering her departing statement. This guy lives next door to a lot of my very close female friends, so it would be real risky for him to try anything on my chick, but it's not implausible.


- Bit of a flirt when we're out and she's drunk, but I suppose not really more than your average chick.


- Regularly leaves her phone laying around next to me unlocked, and her facebook logged in on my computer. Being the ******* that I am, of course I took a look. Couple of messages of guys hitting on her, but her rejecting them saying she has a boyfriend. However, I have spotted her deleting text messages while holding her phone out my my view. Makes me wonder if she purposefully leaves stuff laying around when she knows there wont be anything untoward to be found.

- Recently realised her phone is a DualSim (you can switch between 2 numbers). This makes me curious, but doesn't necessarily mean much considering she's had the phone before I was on the scene.


So what's your verdict? Shall I give her the benefit of the doubt and write it off as me being overly suspicious, keep monitoring, or just full on dump her? My experience tells me that gut instincts usually have something to them, but I've long been a known pessimist when it comes to relationships. I definitely find being a man***** much less complicated.

FYI I still have lots of interest from other girls, and being single is fine by me - which is why I need to know that I'm not giving it all up for a stealth slut.

Outside perspectives appreciated!
 

ovoxo

Don Juan
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
47
Reaction score
2
If you feek the need to go through her phone/facebook the there is no point in the relationship.
 

MM92

Senior Don Juan
Joined
Jan 19, 2012
Messages
303
Reaction score
11
Location
England
ovoxo said:
If you feek the need to go through her phone/facebook the there is no point in the relationship.
My thoughts too, unfortunately.
 

ApolloCreed

Don Juan
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
30
Reaction score
1
ovoxo said:
If you feek the need to go through her phone/facebook the there is no point in the relationship.
Fair point, but in the early stages of a relationship you never know for certain who or what you're really dealing with. Keeping your eyes open can tilt things in your favour.
 

Iceberg

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 19, 2002
Messages
3,115
Reaction score
136
Age
43
Location
Manhattan, NY
ApolloCreed said:
Fair point, but in the early stages of a relationship you never know for certain who or what you're really dealing with. Keeping your eyes open can tilt things in your favour.
You should keep your eyes open before deciding to call it a relationship.

If it's a woman who I mistrust so badly that I have to sneak through her phone, then I'd just keep her around as a f**k buddy. I wouldn't give someone the title of "girlfriend" if I didn't trust her.

Hell, you've been with her for only 2 or 3 months and you're already spying on her. As you get more emotionally attached to her, this habit will get worse. Not better.

So, either you're paranoid or your gut is telling you something about her. Either way, not good for longterm potential
 

In10se

Don Juan
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
154
Reaction score
0
The sexier/more intelligent/ambitious a girl is the more likely you will be to constantly think she has other options. Sounds a bit shady to me, but it also sounds like she is a quality woman who is career driven and devoted to pleasing you. So if she actually does something to disrespect you then tell her that she can't do that **** if she wants the relationship to continue, but until then it you seem like you are just being paranoid...its no surprise that guys who had their eye on her will act hostile towards you...
 

5string

Master Don Juan
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
2,364
Reaction score
112
Location
Standing At The Crossroads
The title of this thread should be, The little guy that sit's on my shoulder told me. Should I believe him?

I would. He's most always right.

Two things:
1)You sound insecure and need to get over that.
2)Trust her until her actions prove her untrustworthy.
 

Thatfeel21

Senior Don Juan
Joined
Oct 22, 2007
Messages
338
Reaction score
103
Location
NJ
:confused:
ovoxo said:
If you feek the need to go through her phone/facebook the there is no point in the relationship.
Painfully true. My gf (at the time) always had her new Android phone lying around. So one night when she was in the shower i decided to play with it cuz my phone is dull and basic and i realized im going to have to learn how to use these phones for when i buy a new one. Well i eventually learned how to navigate her call logs, texts, pictures, etc. I saw a few texts and calls to guys she used to mess with before me and called her out on it. From then on i was constantly checking her phone, fbook messages, etc. Turned into a routine thing whenever she left the room for the bathroom or whatever. Once you open that box, youre screwed.
 

ApolloCreed

Don Juan
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
30
Reaction score
1
Some good advice here.

The situation seems to be one extreme or the other - she's either genuine and a pretty awesome girlfriend (for now at least), or she's extremely devious/I'm majorly paranoid. This gut instinct I have has been shockingly accurate at uncovering things in past relationships, but has also been wrong on several occasions too. In fact I wrongly accused my ex a couple of times, but was totally oblivious when she actually did cheat on me. This may be the reason for my over-analysing with this girl.

Regarding the insecure comment - I'm insecure about relationships and monogamy (including my own ability to be faithful), but not really in myself. I got her hooked on me pretty easily after all.

The snooping is a bit pathetic though, I must admit. Playing private investigator isn't where you should be after 3 months of dating.
 
Top