El Febreezey Da Beez said:
I guess you need me to expand my argument, (Or put it into laymen’s terms). I think that looks do matter in certain situations. On a purely primal level, attraction is usually based on looks, whatever those may be is subjective to that specific person; meaning that different people are attracted to different physical features. Some men like plump women, some women like huge males, some men like short women, some women prefer tall men. So - in essence looks do matter when taking that into consideration. Where you and most everyone else on this thread make a mistake (and yes I am referring to the "looks crowd" as well), is that you are assuming that when someone says "looks matter," they are talking about being a good looking person, which I agree is wrong. Looks matter, but how they matter is completely up to each specific person and what they find attractive. It just so happens that what most people are attracted to on a physical level are symmetrical faces, huge breasts, abs of steel, etc.
In other circumstances looks don't matter, and you have touched upon these circumstances. Confidence - as you have hammered home, is a huge asset to have when a person is looking for something on a level other than a primal or sexual level. The ability to talk well is another; we have all seen guys talk their way into girl's pants. NOW, it is unknown whether that girl slept with the guy who "spit game" solely because he was a good talker, or a combination of looks and game. But since it is unknown, you are right when you argue that the ability to talk and confidence is the key...in some circumstances, not all.
The way I see it, both you and God of getting laid are wrong because you limit your entire argument by polarizing the thread. So stop grouping me with God of getting laid.
So there you have it, that's my view on the subject. Hopefully you understand it now.
I think we are actually on the same page. Heres what the theory Im pushing basically says:
It says that attractive women place a strong importance on looks (statistically speaking). There will be a small percentage of the "attractive women" population that dont, but they are not the typical attractive women. As you move towards less attractive women, the less this applies. ugly women see past looks, so do average women, this is becuase they cant really afford to be picky since they arent exactly in high demand by men. But statistically, this isnt always true either. THere will be some fug women that place high importance on looks and will not date ugly guys. Although these women obviously are often single by choice and they dont make up the typical fug/average women population.
Another important part of the theory is that what is "good looking" is partly subjective. Some women see tall guys as attractive, another may prefer short guys, some chicks actually like really big beefy muscle guys, others prefer them alittle slim. But one thing remains in common, they will only find the guy attractive if he has the right height for her, or the right body type for her, or the right facial structure for her etc. even if the "right face/height/etc" would be considered ugly to most women. So just becuase one women may like big noses in no way means looks dont matter; becuase she chose the guy because of his big nose, it means its the way his nose looks that dictated if she found him attractive, not how he acted. This is the part of the theory that can confuse some people. some people think that because the woman liked a guy becuase he had a physical characteristic that would typically be considered unattractive, it means that the way a man looks must not be a factor in what contributes to weither or not he can get a woman. such an interpretation is incorrect.
I also acknowledge that looks arent the only factor in my theory, though I dont emphasise this much. It works like this: she has to find you attractive, or nothing will work, no perfect game will work. If she does find you attractive, then weither or not you will succeed will depend on how you act. But one thing is apparent, looks matter alot. If your ugly to the woman, and shes attractive, then chances are, you will not succeed becuase there is a very high chance she will require the guy to be "atleast cute" by her very own personal subjective definition of what cute/attractive is.
In no way am I saying how you act doesnt mean anything. IT is important. But its just that, if your not good looking, and your trying a hottie, then you wont succeed even if your personality is awesome. So it really comes down to "looks matter alot". Basically, looks matter for men in the same way looks matter for a woman trying to get a boyfriend. Personality matters for men in the same way personality matters for a woman trying to get a boyfriend. Even in women, personality is a factor despite the fact that men require a woman to be "atleast cute".