Kill The Messenger

Colossus

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
3,505
Reaction score
547
jophil28 said:
I am going to change sides here.

Usually I take the postion that it is encumbent upon a wife to "stand by her man".
However, if a man are going to assert his just leadership, be dominant and also expect a wife to stay by his side "no matter what ", it is encumbent upon him to make good decisions FOR THE BOTH OF THEM.

JImmy did not.The results prove that.

Fair enough.

I actually thought about this some more after I posted, and I think in this case, her leaving was warranted. I get a little bitter with these stories sometimes. This guy made a decision that made both of their lives harder, and would have likely made her miserable had she moved too. It seemed unnecessary and stressful.

An adventurous move for a single man can be a selfish, impractical move for the married man.
 

jophil28

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
5,216
Reaction score
276
Location
Gold Coast. Aust.
Colossus said:
An adventurous move for a single man can be a selfish, impractical move for the married man.
Exactly what happened in this case !
 

Deep Dish

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 25, 2002
Messages
2,191
Reaction score
167
STRUP:
I think it's been said before, but comedians are students of life. They tend to be pretty much unplugged from the matrix. Chris Rock just happens to be brilliantly humorous in delivering his take.
I notice there are two types of comedy: story telling and observational. I personally don't care for story-telling comedians (e.g. Carlos Mencia) and I have quite the ear for observational humor. My favorite comedians are Lewis Black and Adam Carolla, both absolute masters of observation, and I'd say Chris Rock is probably my third favorite. (And the all-time master of observational humor was Seinfeld.) If there is one thing I appreciate the most in life, it's learning, and I love when I learn from humor. I do find truth in the old saying that half of a joke is the truth.
And most of this is humorous, but I think it is worth noting that the "lose your job, lose your woman" thing is not only fairly accurate, but pretty scary when you think about it.
Yup, and this is why I said this truth about women has more relevance today than two years ago (or longer). People are losing their jobs and losing their homes. I don't have a woman to lose, but it does affect me when out meeting the ladies.
 

The Bat

Master Don Juan
Joined
Dec 12, 2007
Messages
1,035
Reaction score
60
Deep Dish, sorry to take your thread slightly off topic.

Colossus said:
I actually thought about this some more after I posted, and I think in this case, her leaving was warranted. I get a little bitter with these stories sometimes. This guy made a decision that made both of their lives harder, and would have likely made her miserable had she moved too. It seemed unnecessary and stressful.

An adventurous move for a single man can be a selfish, impractical move for the married man.
See here is the thing. In marriage, isn't the guy allowed to make some mistakes? Maybe he put the two of them in an uncomfortable situation, but isn't the essence, the foundation of a good marriage, "through better or worse"....

Nobody has specified how the better or worse comes about...whether by your own actions or external circumstances. Either way, shouldn't one of the goals of marriage to be self-improvement and empowering each other? Essentially, nurturing and ensuring growth of each other?

I'm actually surprised to read some of these responses.

Let me ask you this:

if the situation were reversed, wouldn't you guys blame Jimmy for leaving her? For "not being man enough" to stand by her decision? And for not supporting his wife even though she made a bad decision?
 

Jitterbug

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 12, 2008
Messages
3,218
Reaction score
142
The Bat said:
Let me ask you this:

if the situation were reversed, wouldn't you guys blame Jimmy for leaving her? For "not being man enough" to stand by her decision? And for not supporting his wife even though she made a bad decision?
If his wife dropped everything to go for some hippy job and wanted him to uproot, sacrifice his business and move to another state just to stand by her decision, I think most people here would advise him not to.
 

jophil28

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
5,216
Reaction score
276
Location
Gold Coast. Aust.
The Bat said:
Either way, shouldn't one of the goals of marriage to be self-improvement and empowering each other? Essentially, nurturing and ensuring growth of each other?

?
That sounds like some pop psych advice out of Cosmo.

One of the goals of marriage partners is to make WISE choices for the well being of BOTH of the parties. A choice which is likely to deeply distress your wife needs to be re-nogotiated or abandoned.

Paradoxically, marriage confers more RESPONSIBILITY on men than RIGHTS.
One of our strong qualities is our ability to lay out all the options and run a cost/benefit analysis over each. Women generally are NOT equipped to do this.

Frankly, JImmy made his choice more like a woman would. HE acted on his feelings. HE went to Cali because he WANTED to not, because it was wise or in the long term interest of his marriage.
A man who wants his woman to provide unquestioning support for his decisions first needs to demonstrate that he makes wise choices, not act on wishes, hopes and whims..
 

sodbuster

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jun 11, 2008
Messages
2,572
Reaction score
377
Age
65
Location
South Dakota
My ex-wife wanted me to move to a city 180 miles away to live near her daughter. It would have meant giving up my practice and starting a new one in the new town. It would have probably cost me $500,000 in costs and lost income. I refused, she was mad but got over it. If she would have insisted, we would have been divorced about 6 years earlier. She has no right to make a bad financial decision for both of us[like Jimmy did]. My step-daughter moved back in 2 years,so the point was moot
 

Phyzzle

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jun 19, 2006
Messages
1,967
Reaction score
35
I didn't notice any mention of Jimmy selling one of his pictures or getting any commercial interest in his drawings before showing up in California to - what - put the screws to a gallery owner or two? Are his drawing actually any good? Are they really leagues better than the countless drawings coming into http://www.deviantart.com/#catpath=traditional/drawings&order=24 every hour from unpaid amateurs?

Yep, following your dreams isn't always the right thing, not when your dreams are comically stupid.
 

azanon

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 8, 2006
Messages
2,292
Reaction score
41
The Bat said:
I have a story to relate to this topic.

I have a friend who we will call Jimmy. Jimmy is a smart guy who was going to school to study chemistry and working in a lab on the side to make money and get experience. His dream was to work as a chemist, eventually get his PhD, and maybe start up a business of chemistry of some kind. Ambitious guy and he was well on his way since his grades were top notch and colleagues at the lab always had good things to say about him and his future.

Jimmy met Jenny along the way. Jenny is what some guys on here would call high quality because she came from a stable family, always coy and quiet, very friendly and always nice, and not a girl that you would think is a crazy party girl or promiscuous girl. Needless to say, Jimmy married Jenny and they lived happily ever after, right?

See, one of Jimmy's hobbies was drawing and call it a "change of heart" but he decided that he would rather draw as an animator or graphic artist or whatever than study chemistry for the rest of his life. He was chasing his dream instead of chasing something that he thought was his dream.

Jimmy wanted to move to Cali to pursue his drawing hobby. That meant that he would have to leave behind his job, school, and the house to go live in some studio apartment working minimum wage jobs while trying to land a nice gig. His wife didn't agree. She thought he should just stick it out with chemistry pathway and this "phase" of him wanting to pursue drawing will be eventually over.

Jimmy wasn't having it. He was depressed that his wife wouldn't support him and would hold him back. Fights ensued. And they separated. She took his car because she needs it to go to her job. While he is left by himself bumming rides from his friends. He moved out to Cali but he couldn't sell the house since it was under his wife's name too and she didn't want him to sell it. He has started accumulating massive debts because he can't afford to live out there. Struggling artist, really.

Last I talked to Jimmy, he still sounded depressed and worried about his current predicament. He still "loved" his wife and couldn't understand why such a "nice, quality" girl like her would not support him and move out there with him.

Last I talked to Jenny, she was upset that he left but wasn't "killing" herself because he made a "bad" decision. As I type this, she is in the process of filing for divorce. Jimmy is fvcked even more now. Meanwhile, Jenny is dating around other men with good jobs and a good future (or so I've heard...obviously she is not confirming it otherwise Jimmy could nail her for cheating in divorce court).

The point of the story is that what "seems" like "quality" might not be quality after all. Besides, quality is relative. What may be low quality to me might be high quality to others.

Guys on this forum might be perceptive enough and strong enough to not let the chicks see them sweat at the first sign of trouble. But guys like us are far and few in between. I know countless chumps in real life who perspire beyond reason when that first rain cloud appears. I always wonder how they are going to survive the coming storm and not to mention the reaction by their girlfriend/wife.
Bat asked me by email to give my 2 cents on this:

I agree with most all of the others on this one; I'm all for the man being the primary leader and decision-maker in a family, but I also agree that the "leader" is obligated to make reasonably wise decisions when they're going to dramatically affect everyone involved.

I've asked my wife to move across state lines on 3 different occasions, and all 3 times she complied. However, in every instance, I was moving to a professional job that I had already secured, and in 2 out of 3 times, the move was completely funded by my employer. In the first instance, it was to a job in my specific degree field, and in the last 2 instances, it was for a significant raise, with more promotion potential.

I also think there's some inherent dishonesty in a woman marrying a potentially successful man finishing off his PhD in chemistry only to see him say, "forget all of that I'm going to be an artist instead", after she's now "locked down" in a marriage. You know, a significant display of dishonesty and deceit by the man is potentially a valid reason to let go of a marriage. I believe a woman - especially a high quality woman - has every right to access the man's she's marrying and his potential, and has an inherent right to reassess him if he does a virtual 180 after she marries him. Philosophically, I always put logic/reason above arbitrary, and anthropogenic morals/ethics, so it would only be fair to expect women to work the same way.

The proper way to leave your current career for a new one, is to get the new job first, THEN leave the old job second. I've had lots of people very close to me confuse this logical order and sequence of events. Given that we live in an INTERNATIONAL world now, you don't necessarily HAVE to be living in the exact place where you want a job. Case-and-point, my first job as an aquatic biologist I got was work in a city along "coastal U.S." somewhere. Where did I secure this job? In Arkansas using what they call letters, applications, resumes, the internet, and a telephone.

I think she was right to bail if he failed to listen to reason. Sorry Bat, but I think your friend made a very poor decision. The bright side of things is that it's never too late for him to start doing the right thing.

One more thing. There's the word "job" or "occupation", and there's a completely different word called "hobby". It's unusually rare for these two words to be one in the same. Tell your friend it's possible to have both at the same time. Also tell him to please consider the reason one is "paid" to do a "job" or "occupation" is because most people in their right mind wouldn't do it for free.
 

Colossus

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
3,505
Reaction score
547
^^

I can draw. Ive had stuff published. But drawing does not put food on the table. The rare guys who do make money off of illustration, especially drawing, are really, really good, really lucky, and established.

A PhD in chem will almost certainly put food on the table. It's a profession with a lot of training and many applications. I dont think Bat's friend Jimmy was being dishonest, he was just acting AS IF he werent married. Even if he was single, dropping a doctorate-level career in science to pursue drawing is ridiculous...even if you are very talented. The 'proper' way to go about it would have been to see things through in his chosen field while submitting artwork and networking in his off time. Then, and only then, if something viable came up he could weigh the jump in careers.
 

At this point you probably have a woman (or multiple women) chasing you around, calling you all the time, wanting to be with you. So let's talk about how to KEEP a woman interested in you once you have her. This is BIG! There is nothing worse than getting dumped by a woman that you really, really like.

Quote taken from The SoSuave Guide to Women and Dating, which you can read for FREE.

ElChoclo

Master Don Juan
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
593
Reaction score
11
Location
Sydney
I have an uncle who is a saint. Some years ago he had a car crash and almost got killed. He was left with brain damage and bad health. Couldn't work full time. His wife left him of course. Up until the accident he would have been the ideal husband but he still got dumped.

You can kid yourself as much as you want about "quality women", if you were to end up in a wheelchair through no fault of your own, the "in sickness and health" part of the vow will go out the window real fast. Probably after the last cent of personal injury compensation has been wrung by her out of your failing feeble body.
 

squirrels

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 15, 2003
Messages
6,627
Reaction score
178
Age
45
Location
A universe...where heartbreak and sadness have bee
jophil28 said:
I am going to change sides here.

Usually I take the postion that it is encumbent upon a wife to "stand by her man".
However, if a man are going to assert his just leadership, be dominant and also expect a wife to stay by his side "no matter what ", it is encumbent upon him to make good decisions FOR THE BOTH OF THEM.

JImmy did not.The results prove that.
True.

If Jimmy wanted to roll the dice on a pipe-dream, he shouldn't have gotten married.

But which was the bad decision? Chasing the dream? Or bringing a woman into a life that you YOURSELF were not satisfied with??

I envy Jimmy's ability to just pick up and chase something, to "live simple". And maybe he's hating it right now, but he's one of those few who managed to say, "F the world". A more gradual plan would've had more rational hope for success, but the "shock" of moving into squalor might be a motivating factor. Who knows? How "good" our decisions were will largely be based on how well our gambles pay off. If he makes it big and becomes the next Charles Schultz, the decision will be lauded as a bold defiance of society. If he flops, people will regard it as a massive mistake.

The problem is that Jimmy draws his sense of self-worth from a woman.

There's another problem at work here. Jimmy has paid the ultimate price with this girl because I don't think he was HONEST with her up-front. He kept this dream of his hidden from her and married her WITHOUT her understanding a very deep and fundamental part of who he was. Then when he reveals it to her, she's like, "Whoah I didn't sign on for this!!"

Jimmy is bold enough to defy society, to say, "I don't care if I fail, I'm going to do what I love!" But he wasn't bold enough to do that with the woman he loved, because he was DEPENDENT on her for VALIDATION. So while he was secretly preparing to tell society, "Balls to 'success', I'm chasing the dream!", out of the other corner of his mouth he was telling his woman, "I'm looking for a secure, successful career and won't do anything to upset that."

That's why all of this bullsh!t deception, trying to run lines and "game" and convince women that you're more or less than you are ultimately bites you in the ass. Sooner or later, you're gonna have to drop all the game and show her who you REALLY are. Or you'll have to LIVE UP to the "game" that you've been spitting.

Jimmy's entire life is a result of him not being true to himself. He deceived himself into thinking he'd be happy running a chemistry business, then he deceived his girl into thinking he wanted a simple, stable life.
 

Jitterbug

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 12, 2008
Messages
3,218
Reaction score
142
Come on now, you're just overdramatizing it. He wasn't defying society. Society allows him the freedom to quit his career and chase a pipe dream. Society didn't put any barrier in place to stop him from doing anything. Society didn't hold a gun to his head and make him stay in his chemistry business. He was just defying logic & reason. He's no rebel.
 

S.S.N. 318

Don Juan
Joined
Jan 3, 2005
Messages
122
Reaction score
0
Age
43
Location
318/404 (South Coast)
Colossus said:
An adventurous move for a single man can be a selfish...
And how is that Colossus?

Beacuse the city I live in (Monroe), women got attitude problems and they think there divaz, but not (Average Women think they better than anybody..sad) And im try to get out of here and move to Atlanta to start a rap/video game/ or porno career. Cuz women here in Monroe are mostly stanks who got bad attitude and I feel like (sometime) I dont feel appreciated at all.....And im ready to start all over again and mos def loose some weight cuz im bout 300 poundz...

Just curious on it....

Holla...
 

Peace and Quiet

If you currently have too many women chasing you, calling you, harassing you, knocking on your door at 2 o'clock in the morning... then I have the simple solution for you.

Just read my free ebook 22 Rules for Massive Success With Women and do the opposite of what I recommend.

This will quickly drive all women away from you.

And you will be able to relax and to live your life in peace and quiet.

wait_out

Master Don Juan
Joined
Oct 2, 2008
Messages
590
Reaction score
41
Location
Too many places at once
ElChoclo said:
I have an uncle who is a saint. Some years ago he had a car crash and almost got killed. He was left with brain damage and bad health. Couldn't work full time. His wife left him of course. Up until the accident he would have been the ideal husband but he still got dumped.

You can kid yourself as much as you want about "quality women", if you were to end up in a wheelchair through no fault of your own, the "in sickness and health" part of the vow will go out the window real fast. Probably after the last cent of personal injury compensation has been wrung by her out of your failing feeble body.
1) To be fair, would you stick around either if it happened to your girl?
2) If it happened to you, would you want your girl chained to you if it made her unhappy?
3) If it happened to your girl, would she want you chained to her if she knew it made you unhappy?

Let's not have double standards...
 

ZenGodMod

Senior Don Juan
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
297
Reaction score
11
Jimmy is following his dream and it's about time. Why it has taken him this long to realize it is something that he should take fault for and the consequences of it are thus Jenny leaving him.

I believe Jimmy will be a success after some struggle. What strikes me is that Jenny doesn't believe in him anymore. Or never has, which ever the case. She's done what she is meant to do, which is to follow her own path. She is not meant to be there with Jimmy in his quest to for fill his dream and never was. If Jimmy expected it, it's immature of him.

His lead his life making people believe in his chemistry and not his artistry. His fault alone. In some ways he should understand that Jenny leaving him is the best thing for him. If she stuck around, she would be no help, no good, and no support for him. He would have failed.

His success required Jenny out of the picture. Her payoff is a car and house. His payoff will be the for fulfillment of a dream, his much better off this way.
 

Colossus

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
3,505
Reaction score
547
S.S.N. 318 said:
And how is that Colossus?

Beacuse the city I live in (Monroe), women got attitude problems and they think there divaz, but not (Average Women think they better than anybody..sad) And im try to get out of here and move to Atlanta to start a rap/video game/ or porno career. Cuz women here in Monroe are mostly stanks who got bad attitude and I feel like (sometime) I dont feel appreciated at all.....And im ready to start all over again and mos def loose some weight cuz im bout 300 poundz...

Just curious on it....

Holla...

My point was that a bold and potentially profitable risk (at least in term of experience) for a single guy can be downright selfish and silly if you are married. You have your wife's life to consider as well, not just your own.

Women are women the world over. A 'skank' knows not the bounds of social class.
 

Jitterbug

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 12, 2008
Messages
3,218
Reaction score
142
I was reading this: http://edition.cnn.com/2009/LIVING/worklife/02/05/starbucks.saved.my.life/index.html

and was reminded of this thread when I got to this part:

He can joke about it now, but Gill says he was devastated by his firing.

"I remember walking outside and bursting into tears," he says over a steaming cup of coffee at his current place of employment, a Starbucks in Bronxville, New York. "I was stunned. I knew that that part of my life was over."

That was just the start of a terrible reversal of fortune. In a few short years, Gill, the Yale-educated son of the famed New Yorker writer Brendan Gill, closed the consulting business he started after he was laid off, got divorced and was diagnosed with a brain tumor. He had hit both the rock and the bottom and was continuing to fall.
 
Top