SunnyD, you are a woman (girl). you are insecure about NOT having a boyfriend despite you saying otherwise. ALL WOMEN ARE INSECURE ABOUT THIS---ALL OF THEM!
you are cheating on your bf because you are (have been) shopping for another one--test driving if you will. your current bf is "good enough" but now you think you've found "better". but alas, you are not sure about what to do.
now you are asking us guys for advice on what to do about your new boyfriend? he has nothing to do with this, dumbazz.
the advice is the same for all the AFC's on this site: break up with your current bf, regardless of what happens with your "other" bf. your other bf is irrelevant.
i suppose the consolation prize is that you feel "soooo guilty" about it. crocodile tears, hun, for women are wholly incapable of dealing with this particular emotion, and will do ANYTHING, including lying and cheating and ho'ing, to avoid it (just like you, SunnyD). but a funny thing happens, the irrational creatures that you are: by avoiding it, YOU MAKE IT WORSE!!! for both yourself and the guy you're cheating on. women just don't get this very simple concept. they never will.
if this was a 3-6 month bf, then whatever... but you've been with your current bf for five years? that's different.
you are LIAR and a CHEATER and you feel guilty about it? GOOD!!! you are what drives men (boys) to this site.
BTW, you're really starting out a new relationship on the right foot, huh? both of you have demonstrated that you are more than willing to cheat, on a long term partner. nice!
ask yourself this, sweet cakes: is your new boyfriend really the type of guy you want? you know....a guy that cheats on his girlfriend? hmmmmm....interesting thought, huh?
flat out, clean it up now, then go take a powder (get lost).
PS: i'm just about done puking.