I find this to be totally off base. There was a time in my life when I was young and had what is known as the irrational self confidence. EVERY chick I came across was attracted, and even if they tried to hide it, they couldn't for Long. Those days are long gone, but still there isnt a girl out there that doesnt find me handsome. I just dont have the confidence i once had to effortlessly get any girl I want like back then.
Trust me, EVERY girl you came across wasn't attracted to you. At that time in your life you
thought this was the case, and now that you're older, you're tapping into that outdated, childish memory.
You're not able to get any girl you want now because part of you has recognized the reality that you can't be universally attractive, while the other part is living in the past, childish belief system.
You yourself called your youthful self-confidence
irrational. You had a huge rose-colored filter in front of your eyes (your brain, really), and that filter is cracking. The reality is that your idea of "handsomeness" is NOT universally attractive. Women simply don't operate that way.
You "effortlessly" got the subset of girls who hung out where you hung out... girls of the same mindset as you. Girls who liked to be where you liked to be, and when you liked to be there. The majority of girls were elsewhere, doing other things, and having other interests.
Women accept or reject the whole package. Looks are a weak foot in the door. Once that foot is in the door, you've got a millisecond to make the "sale" with your personality. In that millisecond, she decides whether you are her type or not.
Why is it that a guy like you, who describes himself as handsome, has lost his confidence, while I, who rates himself a 7 or maybe on a good day 7.5, have no trouble at all with attraction, no doubts nor lack of confidence? It's because I have thrown out the false perception of universal attraction and instead decided to focus on the plethora of women who give me open invitations with their eyes, faces, and body language.
When you were a kid, your world was small (even though that didn't seem true) and girls were more about looks in terms of attraction toward men. At your age, the world should look a lot bigger, with lots more variation, and you should realize that looks plays a very small (but not insignificant) part in attraction once women mature.
From whence comes your diminished confidence? I would submit that it's because you have noticed that you are rejected by a certain percentage of women although you have perhaps not become fully consciously aware of that yet.
The mythical philosophy of "universal male attraction" unleashes a world of hurt and confusion among men. It comes from the media. In fact, this myth could be the single biggest destroyer of confidence as men get older.
I advise men to cut bait, get out of the middle of the ocean and find a nice little cove where the fish are literally jumping into their boats.