My issue with the covered call crowd is that they are trying to avoid having to learn valuation and pricing models for options. I don't blame them for not wanting to have to do so - you gotta be Rainman to understand that sh!t. Black Scholes is like a kindergarten primer, and almost no one really understands it. I don't want to learn it, either, but that's why I would never trade options. I always try to encourage people to not get into options until you are already making money in stocks. It's like trying to ride a motorcycle before you can ride a bicycle.
I have two degrees in engineering which involved studies in Multi-variate calculus/ Differential equations and solving a very similar second order PDE ( The heat equation) to Black Schoels. Moral of the story is that its not really possible to be able to simply visualize something like that without good understanding of boundary conditions and the transients etc. The Black Schoels formula is the same thing.
I decided to take a look at Option pricing models and understand what goes into them. I'll save everyone the time- its not worth trying to explore. People think stocks are difficult because one essentially needs to predict a direction ( long or short). Options you need to get a multitude of factors right - implied volatility, time to expiration, forward price, etc. To get to the point where you might have an *edge*, you'd have to have a good understanding of a probability distribution function ( not just a normal one, but a log-normal). If you can't "predict" the trend of a stock, good luck predicting the distributions of price, or how volatility changes with time to expiration, underlying price etc.
Now I get that one can get programs to model these things, but even a sophisticated library and model is only as good as the parameters one feeds in. Even with practice, it would be hard for someone with moderate understanding of the models and dynamics to get it right.
For me, I think simple option strategies might be good to mitigate risk. Maybe you want to mitigate downside risk of a market index like SPY so you buy puts as insurance. Something where you know the MAX downside, and in the event of a 2011 or 2008, you can insure part of ones portfolio to a small extent. Maybe you want to catch a stock going up, if you are confident by limiting downside, and buying calls could be a simple way to do that. In my mind, getting into it would involve doing the most basic option plays with LIMITED DOWNSIDE. Insure my portfolio for 2,000 - 3,000 dollars, calculate downside protection, as well as what the potential upside is. Anything beyond that is a fools game..