Good Thread.
Seems to me you guys are arguing a lot about the DJ's intentions. So the "real" Don Juan intents to get as many women as possible and the "moralistic man" intents to get a quality woman.
But isn't a Don Juan mostly about SKILL? Or wasn't it? Wasn't the idea of the Don Juan to be good with women, no matter what you wanted, quality or quantity?
Ever since pook said "The Don Juan is a mindset", people have argued that a Don Juan has to think a certain way, has to have certain morals.
You see, I see myself as a young man playing with fire. Sometimes I wind up burned, sometimes I even burn other people. Yet, the fire fascinates me, it warms my heart and makes me happier, it provides light so I might see things I've never seen before.
Do we really need a closed definition of a Don Juan? Are we about putting up a new one hundred pages long definiton? Are we going to tell the newbie: "Assimilate now!" ?
There is a difference between showing someone a direction (Free you mind, put the focus on yourself, treat women playfully etc.) and giving them an exact roadmap (first you do this and then that and say this, you have to have these morals/no morals at all and your oppinion on growing potatos in your own garden should be this because it's the DJ's oppinion)
Of course, people love someone who tells them exactly what to do. Most people are followers, it's comfortable, and if they can keep following and still be a Don Juan then they are going to say: Yeah, nice, tell me what to do!
Is no moral vs. moralistic man really a contradiction in the sense of being a Don Juan? Both can be good with women. Both are free, since the moralistic man has his own morals that work in his favor. Both can be happy. What is more important than being happy?
I once wrote this article about not limiting yourself. I could care less what the historical Don Juan did. We aren't followers, we make our own path. Moralistic man vs. Don Juan is like black vs. white. We are all grey in a sense.
Everyone here is allowed to present his ideas and insights, so everyone might read and decide what to try out and integrate into his personal style. Stop fighting. Walk your own path. Try to help other people but don't take it personally if they disagree with you. No matter how experienced you are, no matter how inexperienced the person you want to help is, you never know his EXACT circumstances, you can give him advice but not a solution. The solution will be a mix of advice the person got from different people, his own experiences etc.
If we really had two factions on this site with each side holding up their image of a Don Juan it would become pretty boring and uninteresting here. Look for the wind of change and set your sail. No matter where you wind up, it'll be new and insightful.