ok i will sum up from my experiment
i had the same question last year and went around and asked girls what was good and found that there are 3 colongnes i would recomend
1st: curve, simple origional curve id say if your a little active and this is a little more sportier of my 3 choices but still a fresh sent, without being way to strong, and you'll find a lot of girls know of it.
2nd: aqua de gio, this is a very good one that i have recived a lot of compliments on i would where it when im going to sominthing a little more casual like a party to chill or just hangin with a relaxed girl for a calm evening.
3rd armani black code: this is hands down my faviorte and the one with the most compliments. a newer one from armani it is f*ucking great i can tell you instant complements with thisone , its light sent is great for summer or winter and its still very distinctive.all around i have all of these and switch it up as not to be predictable but my faviorte all around is this,
"The Black Code"