True, but is the road to both that different? Lets move on ...Kerpal said:Bodybuilding emphasizes aesthetics. It is about posing various muscle groups for a panel of judges. It has nothing to do with fighting. In combat sports, nobody cares if your 6 pack is symmetrical or not. They are two completely different things.
Wrong. They include sarcoplasmic along with myofibrillar hypertrophy, basically maximize growth. That means you need a range of reps, or at least a number that lies between both ends. You must get stronger in BBing, considerably. Weight gain has nothing to do with routines.Kerpal said:A bodybuilding routine is the absolute last thing a fighter should use. Bodybuilding routines emphasize sarcoplasmic hypertrophy (getting bigger, but not necessarily stronger) thru high reps with lower weight. This leads to unnecessary (from an athlete's point of view) weight gain.
All to do with diet though. You are basically saying forget about volume work and whatnot just focus on low rep bread and butter compounds. Ok fair enough. But the BBs still do those compounds too.Kerpal said:Remember, combat sports have weight classes. A fighter would be much better served using weightlifting and powerlifting principles in their strength training routines because weightlifters and powerlifters know how to train for relative strength and power. In other words, they know how to get very strong without getting a lot heavier.
That's all about diet again, but yes not ideal to get too big.Kerpal said:Also, excessive muscle mass messes up your conditioning. Not to mention that bodybuilding routines emphasize low intensity, long duration cardio to lose fat. This is not optimal conditioning for combat sports, to say the least.
In our level at least, a BBer would do better than the combat guy. BBer still needs to be fit and to be strong, there's no way around that; to have muscle and to have conditioning to get that muscle and low bf. The combat guy would just be small with lagging bodyparts though.Kerpal said:Bodybuilding is a completely different thing from combat sports. Someone who used bodybuilding principles to train for a fight would gas out almost immediately, just like someone who used combat sport training principles to train for a bodybuilding contest would get laughed off the stage.
Again, strength necessitates size MORESO than the reverse, so my point holds moreso than yours ...
MM