When I picked up the most recent girl I was seated with 3 girls (including her) for about 40 minutes. They all studied me, just like in a job interview. In that situation, they can't fake it and neither can you (two friends might fake liking a guy, but 3 girls who don't all know each other can't). Meanwhile, one man can't fake 3 girls at once, one will detect insincerity. Anyhow, I ended up getting two phone numbers and kissed two of them (at the same time). After I left they all huddled and talked about me. Because she was gushing, the two other girls both said my (now) girlfriend should date me (she admitted this to me months later while confessing her love). If the other two girls hated me or even yawned, she most likely would not be dating me now. It's a sad reality that women base their attraction to you on consensus. They want what other girls want. They let other girls screen you for them. For this reason, I have many other girls who would love to steal me away from this girl to prove they are that hot.
So you need to improve your look to the point where a girl and all her friends say "wow, he's hot".