DJDamage said:
Bingo. It happen to me before I found this site and I know how women who harbor baggage and keep in touch with the ex will lead you astray. It is not healthy for both men and women to start a new relationship if they refuse to bury the old one.
No, it's not healthy...but people still do it...and no amount of advising them otherwise will prevent them from doing it. Personally, I make it a habit to unpack any baggage I gain before I move on...but not everyone is able to do that.
Bottom line is this...he's already involved with her. Let's be honest and practical here...he's not going to stop seeing her. If he were he would not be posting to ask for advice. He already cares.
So...everyone can give him the advice to jump ship, which he will ignore.
I think ahead like that, lol. I already know he's going to stay in the situation. Since I also know that this situation doesn't always mean that the girl will go back to the other guy, I'm giving him advice, knowledge and tools that he can put to use that might actually help him resolve the problem and get the result he wants.
Now, regarding your past experience...I'm sorry you got burned. That being said...it's not the same girl, and just like I can't say for certain she won't go back to her ex...you can't say for certain that she will. Since he's not ready to throw in the towel, what's the harm in giving him some advice that might make things work out for him? It worked when someone had that same talk with me...and I didn't leave the guy and go back to my ex. I ended up having a wonderful and very mutually happy relationship with the man who helped me work through the situation. Had he not died I would still be with him right now. Anything could happen with his situation. You guys can't allow your past bad experiences to cause you to run away from the slightest sign of difficulty. Every relationship has rough spots...even great relationships. At some point you need to learn how to face those and deal with them. That is the key to leading a relationship. I'm really trying to teach you guys some very useful tools for communication and conflict resolution with my advice and you guys are so resistant to it. This is amazingly useful and great stuff that really works well in LTRs. Take it in and give it a chance...you might be very surprised at how much it can change your life for the better.