All that is well and good ready, but you're 29. A 29-year-old is more representative of the demographic of males that should be cold approaching. ElStud is 18 and in college. There's absolutely no reason for a guy his age in his situation to be cold approaching. At the very least, he should be cold approaching occasionally, only the girls who catch his eye. Under no circumstances should cold approaching in public be his only venue for meeting girls. There are just too many other good ways at his disposal for him to be meeting girls. I desperately want him to take advantage of them because, when he gets to be in his mid-20s, social life won't be as easy to create. Nor will there be as many quality girls who are his age.
But since ElStud isn't even going to bother considering anything I've written and your post was more of a theoretical dissection, all that is moot. Though, I will still respond to your post for the sake of discussion.
I disagree. Cold approaching to me is just an extension of a confident social personality. It's as simple as realizing you can talk to anyone you want, anytime you want. You don't need to be reliant on situational factors (having your social circle around to up your social value) or listen to social norms tell you that you're only allowed to talk to people at venues like bars and clubs. Basically, you don't need permission to talk to a girl or whoever the hell you want. You're totally in control of your own reality.
There's a big difference between actively cold approaching and being able to cold approach. A strong, confident male should be able to talk to a girl who catches his eye. I'm capable of doing that, and so are many of the other guys who think daytime game is worthless unless you absolutely have to do it. So your point about me needing a social circle to talk to a woman is moot. Same with the point you made about me thinking I need permission to talk to a girl.
In my opinion, you begin to take control of your own reality when you first experience some success. Say for example, a guy starts prizing himself and spinning plates for the first time, and girls start lining up for him accordingly. That's when it really first clicks for a guy. It's then that he takes control of his own reality and realizes that women don't really have the upperhand in the dating game. It's then that he sees that he shouldn't feel guilty about hitting on a girl or approaching one in public.
And one thing I totally don't get is how come people on this board assume it's harder to cold approach than it is to meet a girl in a bar or club.
People on this board assume that day game is harder because it is harder. There's nothing to discuss; it really is just a proven fact. The guys who dedicate their lives to being able to do this stuff in public venues even experience flakes. Doesn't Mystery have something like a 10 percent flake ratio?
Flakes are abundant in cold approaching because the girl isn't expecting to be hit on, whereas at a bar or a club, she is most likely there to meet guys. From an obvious standpoint, a typical girl at a bookstore or a mall could be married or in a committed relationship. Even if she isn't, chances are she's just not mentally prepared to talk to a guy who is a total stranger. I don't care how you're approaching her, whether it's with direct game or with an opinion opener.
At a bar or club, there is also a good chance you could make out with the girl you're approaching or you could dance with her or do something that creates some sort of sexual contact. That should leave a lasting impression on her - enough so that she would be eager to spend time with you again.
Now, I'm not saying a guy shouldn't bother with cold approaching in public. If you see a girl you're attracted to, you should talk to her. Or, if the nightlife scene in your area sucks or you don't have a lot of friends to go out with, cold approach in public till you experience some success. Play a numbers game. You're bound to plow through all the flakes at some point.
In a party environment, you're dealing with lower comprehension level, a loud ass environment, girls that blow you out in seconds based on initial impressions, and practically every girl there will have a cckblock whether its her male cousin or her fat friend who isn't having any fun. And when it comes to flaking, you're gonna have to deal with the huge discrepency in energy level between when you met the girl in the club and when you call her for the day 2. A cold approach in a bookstore is fvckin CAKE compared to a club
This is all relative man. We're arguing apples and oranges now.
I've only ever been blown out or completely shotdown in a bar or club a couple of times, and they were both times when I was so sh!tfaced I barely even knew what I was saying. The fat girl friend and even the older brother can be dealt with, you just have to know how to disarm them.
A cold approach in public moves wayyy too slow, so slow that you can't generate enough rapport and attraction in the short amount of time that you're talking to the girl. This is one of the reasons why flakes are so abundant. The girl basically has to go out on a date with a complete stranger. All she knows about this guy is that he is an interesting guy, he is a hell of conversationalist and that he is physically attractive - that is if you are a good looking dude.
It's the complete opposite in a nightlife setting. The interaction speeds itself along, and often you can escalate fairly quickly, going from an opening line, to some fluffing, to some kino, then to dancing or even making out. In that short time period, you've already accomplished a date worth of escalation. This is why ONS's happen in bars and at clubs, not at the bookstore.
You guys having more flake issues on a cold approach than a club approach, I have no clue why, it makes no sense to me. You guys are probably coming across creepier than you think
This is complete bullsh!t though. I experience flakes because I'm coming off as creepy? That is laughable.
C'mon man.
To be completely honest with you, I don't believe for one second that you or anyone else who solely uses daygame are as successful as a guy who uses his social circle or the nightlife to meet women. I'm not trying to call you out or anything, I'm speaking from my experience of my own and from talking to other posters on this site. No one experiences an abundance of success from cold approaching in public. It really is just that simple.