I've tried the low carb approach myself, and I agree with many of the critiques that were mentioned in my previous post: low carb diets are potentially hazardous to your health and they make you sluggish and tired, which eliminates your ability to perform the kinds of exercise that help put on lean muscle.
Hazardous to your health? No, not unless you are a diabetic and develop ketoacidosis. I agree that low carb diets are not ideal if you want to gain muscle or if you perform high intensity exercise/training. A way to combat this is by using a cyclical ketogenic diet or targeted ketogenic diet, where you include "refeeds" or "carb-ups". Your training volume is excessive, hence why you struggled with low carb.
You didn’t read the articles did you. Many of the articles are expert medical opinions based on scientific studies that have been cited within the article, including the longest and largest one of its kind which looked at over 43,000 people over a 15 year period. All of the opinions – by doctors and nutritionists experienced in treating obesity – explain the health risks associated with low carb dieting as well as the reasons why people don’t stick with them.
The only health risks are for diabetics which I mentioned in this post and my previous post. Do you know that ketogenic diets are prescribed for people with epilepsy and markedly improve the incidence of seizures? Adherance issues don't necessarily imply that a keto diet is bad or ineffective, just not suited to the person.
Finally, I did not mention the NY Times articles as clinical proof of the ineffectiveness of low carb diets. I brought it up as proof from food industry executives that low carb diets are becoming more and more unpopular, and that they are much more difficult to stick to than other, more well balanced nutrition plans. I mentioned the Daily Mail article because it discussed a scientific study in which most of the people studied actually dropped out because they could no longer stand the monotony of a low carb diet plan.
Adherance.
I'd strongly advise against obtaining all of your health and nutrition information from a single source, this might explain your tunnel vision in this as well as in other matters.
I'm not married to one type of dieting or training. I prescribe what is most suited to the person, not just hand out cookie cutter eating plans/training routines. Lyle Mcdonald has been in the industry for more than 15 years, while many others have come and gone. His information is correct and ridiculously detailed. Other people in the industry that I follow are Alan Aragon, Martin Berkhan, Børge Fagerli and many others. I gave the link for www.bodyrecomposition.com because it is the most comprehensive site available for both training and nutrition. Ketogenic diets, high carbohydrate diets and everything in between.