Duffdog said:
The fact that you actually believe this statement makes it very difficult to explain any advanced concepts that deal with your field.....blah, blah, blah....
I brought up my intelligence because for some reason you keep talking about how I'm not smart enough to understand this and that because I don't have an "advanced degree", as if that is the only way that a person could comprehend what you are saying.
I'm not sure exactly what it is you have against people who think differently than you do, but when you resort to passive aggressive taunts and incoherent babbling as opposed to answering the questions I posed and explaining WHY you believe what you believe, I have no reason to respond. I know it must make your head hurt when you are presented with ideas that go against your narrow view of the world,
but if you are going to try to discredit someone you should at least be able to make a case for it.
And now to respond to people who WANT to learn......
CosMoenTropic said:
However, in order to build wealth according to your philosophy, one needs some kind of spark, or be in the right place at the right time, and to have everything fall right into place (opportunities come your way, the possibility of failure and risk never seem to enter the equation). I like your optimistic outlook, but don't we need to realistic sometimes?
If you wait around for the "right time" you will be waiting forever.
Some of the richest men in history started with nothing, and many lost their fortunes one or more times as they went along.
What exactly IS "realistic"?
This is what separates the guys who are buying islands at age 22, and guys who are practically destitute in their retirement years- their concept of what is realistic and what isn't.
I have always had the drive, but I didn't learn this until I was well in my 30's. I learned it the HARD way, because I had many of the concepts of reality that were instilled in me from my childhood. It took a lot of trial and error and a lot of pushing myself into unfamiliar territory and eventually realizing that the boogeymen that were supposedly there didn't even exist, but eventually it clicked that many of the limitations we have are self imposed and can be lifted by trying new things. And to be perfectly honest with you, to this very day I still start a new project with radical misconceptions about things. I see "boogeymen" that aren't really there. But I push myself to try new things, and each time I shatter a new barrier. It's a great feeling.
I think the best advice is to get a good education, and have a decent salary first. Then, learn to SAVE! Start depositing into CD's, money markets, mutual funds, etc as a start.
The "best" advice depends upon who the advice is given to.
For the risk averse person who would be worried to death about losing a penny, the best course of action might be to live like a hermit your entire life. There are people that are like this. When you die your kids sell your house and the people who buy it decide to put a swimming pool in the back yard and find a box buried with $500,000 in cash in it, while you lived in a roach infested cesspool. An extreme example for sure, but it does happen, and I personally don't want to live that way.....
The point I am trying to make is that some people just aren't cut out for it. Are you? The only person who can answer that is YOU.
Then once you have enough capital and a job to fall back on can you start learning to wise up and do your own investing. Do you agree with this idea?
I don't agree or disagree. That is one way of doing it. Another way is to go balls to the wall, sell everything you own and jump in head first.
Realistically, you will probably be somewhere in the middle. I did a stint in college and worked in sales, hospitality, and briefly in construction before I took the plunge. I did it when the time was right for ME. But to be honest with you I had to force myself to do it because I felt conmfortable suckling from the teat of "the system" that paid my bills.
It was very, very rough the first couple of years, but eventually I learned enough that I started making enough money to pay my bills, and from that point i never looked back.
Or do you believe people can just jump into the whole independent, money generating scheme and rely on that for the rest of their lives?
Whoa....whoa.....now you sound like some of the other posters.
This is no "scheme". It is not magical. It is not a get rich quick deal. It will require WORK. It will require SACRIFICE. It will require stepping out of your comfort zone.
Your examples all make sense, but they are very idealized and sometimes impractical if one doesn't take your advice with a grain of salt.
There is nothing idealized about it. You think this way because it is not within what you consider to be realistic due to the fact that you have never tried it.
A lot of people think that the "gurus" are being intentionally vague in what they teach, but it isn't that at all. There are many ways to skin a cat, and there is no "one size fits all" treasure map to wealth. If it were that simple THAT is what they would be selling and everyone would be wealthy, but it doesn't work that way.
Do you know how many PM's I got over the course of this thread asking me EXACTLY what they need to do to become wealthy? TONS. And my answer was the same every time- read what I posted, read the books I recommended, and go out there and DO SOMETHING. Even if you fall flat on your face. You have to create YOUR OWN personal treasure map based upon what you learn and your individual situation and even your personality.
For me, at least, I feel learning how to save and control spending habits is much more important than going out and investing as a primary source of income. If the majority of professionals cannot consistently beat the market, how can individuals rely on it as a steady income stream?
First off, I'm not recommending you try to "beat the market". I am recommending that you give yourself a competitive advantage by learning creative methods to acquire assets, and try, try, TRY, even if you fail, fail, FAIL. If you fail enough times you will eventually find your niche and it will all come together.
Secondly, there are two ways to increase your wealth- living below your means, or increasing your means.
What you are proposing is living below your means, or
contraction. You make $50k, you spend $40k, you have $10k left over.
The problem with this is that your potential is limited. You can't save less than you make. If you make $50k and somehow you find a way to not ever spend a penny, you are still limited to having $50k left over.
It is much better to look at it from the other side of the coin, to INCREASE your means, to
expand.
Some folks earn millions of dollar per year in salary. That isn't realistic for us mere mortals who aren't 7 feet tall and able to dunk a basketball or those of us who can't cry on cue in front of a movie camera. So the rest of us have to find other ways to expand our means. You can do this many different ways (creating your own treasure map) but the idea is to get involved in one or more of the asset classes (stocks, business, real estate) and learn how to increase your means exponentially.
Essentially, you shouldn't be saying "I can't afford that", you should be asking yourself "How CAN I afford that"?
I agree having a degree without your sense of financial street smart is useless, but IMO investing and starting your own business should be left to those with some disposable income first ie.
Having a degree is NOT useless, but you must learn to see it for what it is, which is a tool that allows you to obtain a job that can produce an income. That might be part of your individual plan, your "treasure map", but if it is the only thing you aren't going to go very far very fast.
What advice do you have for recent college graduates by the way? Again, I like your style of thinking, but some of it is a bit too radical to me
My advice for a recent college grad would be to pursue an occupation in your chosen field. Try it out. Maybe you will absolutely love it. If so, you can always do things on the side that can bring you closer to financial security.
Feel it out, but if you are like me and don't want to be working 40 hour weeks when you are 60, set a goal and figure out what it will take to get there. If your goal is to retire by the age of 55 and you are just getting out of college, you won't need to get aggressive starting businesses and such if that isn't your thing. Learn about the stock market, and maybe dabble in real estate.
If you are wanting to retire by the age of 40 or sooner you will probably have to learn to stomach higher risk (which is proportionate to your level of knowledge and can be negated by such) and you are going to have to learn how to do things other people will tell you are impossible. You have to be willing to sacrifice and willing to accept failure.
Whatever you do, don't listen to all of the people who say you can't do this or you shouldn't do that. As you can see by several posts in this thread there are plenty of them out there. These people are the AFC's of the world of money. All they are is crabs in a barrel trying to pull you back in.
You are better than that.