BaronOfHair
Master Don Juan
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2024
- Messages
- 2,680
- Reaction score
- 1,164
- Age
- 35
Reminds me of the following https://www.thesunmagazine.org/issues/350/can-the-left-get-it-rightYes, I know about that, I have American friends and we talked pretty much daily about 9/11 and the aftermath.
Quote -
"Polonsky: I thought the antiwar movement expressed its position with intelligence.
Shellenberger: What I fault the antiwar movement for is that it was never very clear about what it stood for, neither its core values nor its vision for U.S. engagement in the world. The message coming out of the mainstream antiwar groups before the invasion of Iraq was “Let the inspections work.” What kind of vision and values did that elevate?"
And:
"Polonsky: The all-or-nothing debate reminds me of my activist days in the eighties. There was a certain counter-cultural identity within the peace movement. You had a sense of being more bohemian and hip than the mainstream. That identity was pleasant for us, but I don’t think it served our overall objectives"
The Manosphere is similar to "Progressives" of The 2000s in more ways than most realize... Just as the latter deserves credit for not blindly going along with the invasion of Iraq/The War On Terror more generally(At a time when, as Noam Chomsky has noted, The US MSM was Pravda-esque in it's genuflection towards The Bush Regime), the former deserves credit for challenging the "Men Evil, Women Helpless Prey" mantra that was regurgitated without question in most of the mainstream press. Ultimately though, neither was especially effective, in terms of securing concrete and tangible gains
Bush II won a second term, and didn't really experience a faltering in his popularity, until the very end of his Presidency. Everyday Americans just got bored with Iraq, thus support for a War On Terror began to evaporate... Activists and intellectuals had very little influence over any of this. Donald Trump didn't turn out to be The Mahdi so much of The Manosphere anticipated, and MeToo no longer being at the forefront of our cultural Zeitgeist is largely attributable the public's attention moving on to other fixations, rather than a large cross-section of America being persuaded that stereotypes about men are gross oversimplifications. The Manosphere never became anything more than a subculture