Your EASY and not at all a challenge to the girls you are OVERLY interested in on your first date. Think of it as the male version of the fugly female slut that will hang out but never bang and isn't very interesting.
You are not giving them the gift of mystery (aka making them wonder about if you like them or not),
You are instead being very overt that you like them.
Like a dog chasing its owner around happy for any attention. Women (esp. those in demand) are much, much more attracted to hot, confident men who they aren't sure are into them or not.
So with the ones you want, do this differently:
1. Stop complimenting them - The MOST you are allowed to say is 1 time "You look nice" - that's it
2. Do NOT touch them first. have a good time, be close enough but let HER touch you first. That is the invitation to touch her SOME
3. Absolutely make the move to kiss them at the end of the date, even if she rejects you it will get her mind turning and keep you thoroughly out of friends zone
4. Do NOT call them the next day after the date. Let them call you. Even if you f*ck her
5. If they don't call you, wait 4 days and text a max of 3 back and forth before you ask her out again.
6. No texting in between dates. The phone is for setting up dates ONLY
7. Hang back w/ body language on dates don't lean in
8. SHUT UP, let her talk about herself, try to get to know as much about her ask you can, while having a light hearted, good time.
9. When she asks about you, give her as little information as possible
10. Be a gentleman, but still have fun and joke around, tease her etc.
11. DOn't answer her phone calls and texts etc. right away, take your time sometimes texting back and call her later.
12. Don't be overly available, sometimes if she proposes a day / time to get together tell her you have plans.