Francisco d'Anconia
Master Don Juan
Here's a question for discussion; what specifically do you gain by getting married?
Let me go out on a limb and and proclaim this to be one of the most succinct and important posts I've yet to read.Sir Drinksalot said:Having been married, I can tell you it's much more complex than one gives it credit for before having done it. Having been divorced, I can tell you the matriarchal/feminist court system all but forces the male to become an AFC. Women go into marriage knowing they've already won the divorce settlement.
I lived with my ex for 5 years before we got married. The difference was subtle but tangible right out of the gate. Her sense of entitlement skyrocketed. She was no longer on her best behavior, because all the marital assets, so she thought, were at least half hers. She no longer had to back down on power struggles because her mother clued her in to how much I'd owe her in child support if one of us walked. Suddenly, her childish whims carried legal weight. It was a recipe for divorce. Our relationship took a turn for the worse right after the honeymoon.
Of course, the reaction to the increased relationship power a woman gains by getting married depends on the woman. I have seen women who are dedicated to the relationship, and mature enough, not to let it affect their behavior. But I don't think this is something you can gauge before taking the plunge, you can only guess.
For a DJ, or any man who wants to control his own life, marriage is Russian Roulette.
Also, a MARRIED DJ is showing AFC characteristics. First and foremost, he's saying to the world that quality women for him are getting scarce. He's also giving the woman what SHE wants, at great expense to himself. Notice, there is no "GROOM" magazine. Men are at best indifferent about getting married. Engagement alone shows large flaws in a DJ's armor.
You spend the rest of your life trying to impress a woman while the rest of us will find better more fulfilling things to do for our lives. Who wants to be playing the game forever..he has to maintain his game, except at a different caliber and field.
You are to young and short sighted to know anything about "a true don juan"A true Don Juan knows his job is never over.
think again Youngin' you got A LOT TO LEARNand no my friend, this is definitely not AFC material.
peace
The PleasureKing
Man I'm really glad you asked this. It's been on my mind a lot recently.Francisco d'Anconia said:Here's a question for discussion; what specifically do you gain by getting married?
So are you saying that a guy can not achieve any of these things (including love) without getting married?PleasureKing said:marriage is the union between a male and a female where security is established financially and emotionally. its a life long commitment couples establish to forever hold them together. the door to procreation is opened to those who are religiously bound together as well....
...but the direct answer to what a man gains in marriage is LOVE, and no my friend, this is definitely not AFC material.
That was a very well thought out answer. Now here's a challenging question for you. Given your views on the subject of marriage, can you try really hard to determine just one benefit to getting married (from a guy's perspective of course). Hey, I didn't say this was going to be easy, just challenging.RedPill said:Man I'm really glad you asked this. It's been on my mind a lot recently.
As I see it, you don't gain jack sh1t. Now, I'm still young and have never been married, but the only purpose that I see it serves is gaining the approval of community/society. You can live with a woman and raise healthy children with a woman, but how specifically does a man gain by giving her such huge leverage over him through a marriage contract?
In today's femme-centric legal system, a man cannot divorce a woman without incurring substantial financial penalties. If women knew that they could be kicked out or replaced at any time without that golden parachute, they would have a hell of a lot more respect for the men that provide for them and their offspring. They would support their men's dreams and work hard to stay hot, provided their husband is a man of substance.
I can't picture myself being married for a very long time from now, if at all. I'm the type of guy though that wants a high degree of control over my life. I'll never 'settle down' and be Mr. Suburbanite Husband who busts my hump to put food on the table for the wife and kids. My life ambitions don't include living out the classic working-class provider role, and will not be shelved so that some woman's dream of white picket fences and a small house full of junk is met.
Is it truly possible, when you have the means to do so, to structure your marriage so that if there is a divorce, the woman does not get to retain any of the assets *you* created both before or during the marriage?
I had to think about this one for a while.Francisco d'Anconia said:Here's a question for discussion; what specifically do you gain by getting married?
Winning, for me atleast, is about overcoming in odds that seem impossible. In an era that presents a 50 percent chance at failing in marriage, winning is beating those odds. Finding a good companion or best friend pooled from someone of the opposite sex who can make you happy and is happy in themselves waking up everyday next to you for the rest of your life is winning. Rasing a fuctional child who thinks of you as his or her hero first despite your faults, is winning. Being old and dying in a lifesupport system with someone who cares more about you then themselves, is winning. Being remembered for the person you were and surviving via the legacy that survived your short time on this earth is winning.dietzcoi said:PR Moon
Define "winning" in your post.. what do you think you will "win"?
Only those of us who have been there can tell you... there is no "winning". I would like to see what a man thinks he has "won" by getting married. Unless you marry a very rich woman, of course
Dietzcoi
Raising kids in a normal environment has always been men's rationale for getting married, but lately it's become less of a requirement. Fifty years ago it was a pretty good place to be, but feminism, negative media portrayals of husbands, and a blatantly sexist judicial system have made marrying American women a mostly painful, unrewarding, expensive torment.PRMoon said:Winning, for me atleast, is about overcoming in odds that seem impossible. In an era that presents a 50 percent chance at failing in marriage, winning is beating those odds. Finding a good companion or best friend pooled from someone of the opposite sex who can make you happy and is happy in themselves waking up everyday next to you for the rest of your life is winning. Rasing a fuctional child who thinks of you as his or her hero first despite your faults, is winning. Being old and dying in a lifesupport system with someone who cares more about you then themselves, is winning. Being remembered for the person you were and surviving via the legacy that survived your short time on this earth is winning.
This sure is the underlying message we get from women, isn't it? Boy they love for you to take this bait, too. They all believe it because it's true for women, because if they don't lock down a man and the "golden parachute" (good observation from somebody's earlier post in this thread), their girlfriends will make them feel like crap for the rest of their lives and they'll be stuck working for the rest of their lives. But it's not the case for men. The older men get, the more women think all men are taken, or gay. So really, you could easily wind up getting married late in the game, not "dying alone," playing doubles shuffleboard in a retirement community against another couple who's been married since age 25 -- without wasting your life busting your a$$ to shut some nagging shrew up, without going through any divorces, spending your life as you see fit.PRMoon said:The concept of that is hard to grasp for many people but that's your life layed out for the next 40 plus years lain out. Your name will not be mentioned in history books. No one outside of your family will remember who you were outside of 100 years. That is your destiny, like it or not you are doomed to an eternity of nothingness. Trust me when I say you will not be able to game girls until your mid 50's to 90's if you make it that far. You will not be happy in your life after you reach that point and are alone with no one to enjoy life with. The big question is where do you start realizing this fact and when do you start acting on that notion before it's too late.
This varies by individual, so I have 2:Francisco d'Anconia said:Here's a question for discussion; what specifically do you gain by getting married?
I wish I could confirm this as truth, for the basic reason that you're a smart guy and have some good advise. Unfortunately, its not because, for starters, we have 2 people (you and me) that are 1. here and 2. both have successful marriages. I presume you do (now) realize your testimony about your successful marriage, the statement i quoted from you above and your being here is inherently condradictory?Guys with successful marriages (a dubious term at best) don't really have the motivation to come to forums like this and share their insights. Why bother if that area of one's life is more or less taken care of? So in light of this, I'll share a few things I've learned in the last 10 years that make for a good marriage from my perspective.
So I pose a question to you that's similar to one I asked someone else in the thread; was getting married the only way to having excellent children and gaining life experience?grinder said:This varies by individual, so I have 2:
1) Excellent children! I am so thankful for them.
2) Life experience.
I remember a thread recently on what are the top things people wanted to do. Despite the obvious massiveness of this institution, few put marriage on the list.
If you wish to become like tempered steel, you need to immerse your hot blade into some cold places.
I see what you're saying and this is definately true for most guys. I do however think that I'm outside of this definition. For some reason, most of the girls i've had lasting relationships with, have all been weathy. I don't just mean doing well in a bartending job, I mean parents are millionares, and they've got stock options in their names. I have no explination for why this happens other then citing my time in private school where I associated with rich chicks daily and maybe became kind of use to or attracted to this type. The effort is subconsious though. I don't go around asking girls if their rich or to see their bank account statments before I agree to go out with them. I look at them as normal girls, we start dating, sooner or later they break it too me that they've got money or i realize it myself.Sir Drinksalot said:Raising kids in a normal environment has always been men's rationale for getting married, but lately it's become less of a requirement. Fifty years ago it was a pretty good place to be, but feminism, negative media portrayals of husbands, and a blatantly sexist judicial system have made marrying American women a mostly painful, unrewarding, expensive torment.
Of all my friends, two of them have marriages that I actually think are worthwhile because the women they married are willing to let them be who they are, don't attempt to control them or stifle them. But that's not normal. Most of the married guys I know have wives who harp on them about everything from remodeling the house, landscaping, getting a new car, going on vacation, staying home from work more, sending the kids to private school, you name it. American wives will bicker for decades about these things to feel power over their men, to impress their girlfriends and mothers, or just to keep their husband's attention out of insecurity. All the while, her respect for her husband erodes as her weight goes up and attractiveness declines. After a decade, you might not even be attracted to her, but you'll be more obligated than ever to provide for her.
This sure is the underlying message we get from women, isn't it? Boy they love for you to take this bait, too. They all believe it because it's true for women, because if they don't lock down a man and the "golden parachute" (good observation from somebody's earlier post in this thread), their girlfriends will make them feel like crap for the rest of their lives and they'll be stuck working for the rest of their lives. But it's not the case for men. The older men get, the more women think all men are taken, or gay. So really, you could easily wind up getting married late in the game, not "dying alone," playing doubles shuffleboard in a retirement community against another couple who's been married since age 25 -- without wasting your life busting your a$$ to shut some nagging shrew up, without going through any divorces, spending your life as you see fit.
I actually agree. In fact...put things in perspective for many people (even those that were married before).KarmaSutra said:Let me go out on a limb and and proclaim this to be one of the most succinct and important posts I've yet to read.