Agree it’s overrated. I think a problem with it is that it usually comes with some level of expectation from one or both parties just by operation of them having the mutual friend who fills their heads with said expectations of what the other person is going to be like. “You two are perfect for each other” when you are anything but - but go in with this expectation that this person is really something. Experienced men can know better.
Social circle setups that fail usually fail because its a setup solely based on 2 people having the same social connection and their primary commonality at that moment is an unattached status.
Experienced men often know that they can find more compatible options outside of their social sphere.
For Average Frustrated Chump beta types, this often represents one of their best options.
Bigger issue is the lack of options from it there are usually very few highly attractive, single friends in a social group unless they happen to be inbetween LTRs.
In my mind as I respond to this, I'm doing a thought experiment about how this would play out with my local female social connections.
I don't have any female friends locally right now. I have some acquaintances, mainly in the wives of my male friends. I have some former female co-workers I could broach the subject with at this moment.
My male friends wives have social connections that are typically married women and married women with children 10 and under. The wives also rarely see me and don't have much of an opinion on me. It depends on the specific wife we are talking about here. There are wives of my male friends that I haven't seen in 5+ years.
I have some former female co-workers who I know well enough to ask for introductions. However, I know the general types of people they know. They know most married people with children under 18 and a few single moms. They don't know the types of women I'm seeking in general.
I don't have any social circle options at the moment and have never really had them.
My options are approaching strangers in real life, swipe apps, and sending DMs on social media.
I've chosen to focus on approaching strangers in real life.