I think the OP is noting how a lot of gurus give “One size fits all” advice based on their personality/profile. That’s a valid criticism.
You need to develop your own “game” and/or find a guru that you identify with best.
I don't tend to get too involved in 'game convos nowadays as I think it's basically irrelevant and far from the most important thing when we're talking about getting laid with cold approach
However, i'll say that many years ago (before i'd consumed and tested literally every premium premium products PUA teachings) one of my first 'alarm bells' about the potential of this all being a load of nonsense was when I realised that not only did the coaches all disagree on everything with the 'theory' of game (should have been a big hint in hindsight) but it was clear that their 'vibes' were also all so different
Their vibe was their personality. And that personality dictated the words that left their mouths and how they all acted! And of course they were all SO different.
I'd watch an infield by 'mystery' or something, and i'd think, 'OK, so not only is it about the negs and his DHV stories and his 'bait-release' concepts etc, but his 'vibe' seems to be trying too adopt a kind of mysterious, slightly serious relaxed vibe. Cool, I get it''
And then i'd stumble upon someone like RSDJeffy who was kind of the polar opposite. His vibe was way more playful and loud and 'out there'. Forward, jokey, sexual. Not afraid of unearned compliments etc. And of course this all dictated the words that left his mouth. LIke most noobs at the time, I was interested in 'verbal game' - e.g exactly what am I supposed to say too a girl to MAKE her want to bang me if i'm not her physical type?!!' but it became clear that no only was that impossible (trust me. I tested it all), but the 'vibe' was seemingly irrelevant anyway!
And then there was every variation of 'game' you could imagine with other pros (because we all have different personalities!!!).
So people were essentially trying to learn to adopt someone elses personality to the point they'd need a brain transplant if they'd ever hope of coming out with the same questions, statements, answers etc as their favourite guru! lol
What became obvious very fast was that there was clearly no rules! And since there's no rules, there's no game! A game isn't a game without rules.
All of these PUA's got laid a lot and they got rejected a lot. Same as any other guy on the street who'd never heard of game
You can be indirect, you can be direct, you can be jokey, you can be serious, you can compliment, you can never compliment, etc etc.
People get laid in spite of this stuff. Not because of it
What got them their results was the fact that they put the odds in their favour through sheer numbers game (approach enough girls and you'll stumble upon the yes girls. And there's nobody who can do better than that. )
Nobody has every blown my mind or impressed me / surprised me when it comes to this stuff. Including the apparent best in the world/top PUA coaches.
Everyone gets the results i'd expect. The same results i'd get in their bodies.
I can look at a guy for 2 seconds and know how he will fair in the club tonight if he's gonna hit on the sort of girls I want.