When you don't have organic interactions with women consistently, they can tell. Even if your calibration is off by .01%, it tells them a lot about you.
For example, valuing a phone number is the cringiest thing in the world. It can turn a 10/10 guy into a 1. In her mind, she cannot believe she is that important. So imagine how she would feel if you value her number?
Another example is talking to a 7 but treating her like a 10 and turning her off. If you are not used to talking to 7's on a consistent basis, the 7 WILL look like a 10. Your eyes will play tricks on you.
There's a million other things that can make you seem "weird" and "off" if you are not constantly living amongst women.
Over-valuing them, under-valuing them (too much c0cky funny), being to eager, being too easy, not being easy enough, etc, etc. Every situation is different. Sometimes you have to move forward, sometimes you have to move back. You can't just blindly take a technique you saw online and apply it to everything.
But all it takes is like 1 month of interacting with women daily and you are cured through the process of osmosis.
No website, guru, dating manual, or seduction techniques can replace real world calibration.
You would seem like a genius to the rest of us just through osmosis and proximity to women alone.
That's the fatal flaw of seduction communities. In an effort to understand women, we forget to tell guys to be around them. And guys throwing away real world experience and trusting online gurus. It's comical.
And this one takes the cake: Some of us have real world experience but we are told we have no idea what we are talking about because what we say does not align with the online seduction community.
The way you are wording this makes sense to me now and I feel is the actual issue.
As I've mentioned, I've had very attractive and hot women initiate with me and ask me out but every single time it always fell flat. Granted, every single situation was different, the women were different, etc.
I had a light skinned black girl at my gym initiate with me, easily a 9/10 and she has over 5k followers on instagram, which I found about out later. Anyway, she used to check me out all the time but she semi initiated when I held the door open for her, she smiles, says hi, etc. I later end up approaching her, she has a huge smile on her face, we talk for a few minutes but I end up running out of things to say and it got awkward kind of quick. She looked down and away, as if she was disappointed and lost all interest, so I walked away at a loss.If I had played that differently it clearly would have worked in my favor.
I have a few other fairly recent stories that played out like this, where really hot/attractive women actually asked me out but later ghosted and stopped talking to me out of nowhere.
I have a 8-9/10 hot fit white girl at my gym who goes there with her bf all the time and she's tried talking to me at the grocery store next door when he isn't around, though I don't encourage that. I would show you pictures of these women but I'm not going to do that out of concern for their privacy, which I'm sure you understand.
This was from a while ago, but I was on a date with a woman and she was having a really good time, asking me tons of questions about myself. We were sitting down next to each other on a bench when were chatting, she was touching me a few times on the leg and arm. Anyway, I put my hand on the inside of her knee/thigh and she didn't like that at all, afterwards it totally changed the manner of which she interacted with me. Now, I had no intention of raping or hurting her, as it was just a gesture to show her that I wanted her and was attracted to her, but she obviously didn't perceive it to be that way.
My issue doesn't have to do with attractiveness but I think what you are mentioning on here.
I do want you and others to understand though that I am actually a normal person, meaning I'm not going to flat earth meetings, performing satanic rituals at my house, etc. I do in fact have a lot of friends and have a life, though as I mentioned I rarely interact with women.