I also noticed
@GrowingPains asked you to name your faults, and this was followed by a post of you naming all your attributes (again). You have to admit your problem if you're ever going to work on fixing it.
Of course they do, women care about almost everything when it comes to dating.
Sounds like you specifically want a gym rat. This is one reason why no one appeals to you, you're too picky. You live in Chicago, FFS, it's the third most populated city in the US. There are plenty of women there, but you can't find one.
I'm wondering where you would find a gym rat outside of the gym? Marathons? I'm guessing "runner's bodies" don't appeal to you.
Some other sort of athletic competition? Maybe you could go to a WNBA game. There was a Saturday Night Live skit recently on guys who tried to pick up WNBA players.
You're always talking about how much money people make. You sound a bit stuck up, to be honest.