Good looks and high quality traits definitely helps in that first step of attraction, and its always the first thing guys see when they put up fake ads like this, but it also creates its own hurdles (especially online). The fact that "Chad" only had 7 matches in 2 days is not an accident, because your own (real) social acuity and personality is still being conveyed no matter what you wrote in the bio.
A lot of women will look at such an ad with the same kind of skepticism that a man will have towards a hottie with her own ad; usually too good to be true (fake) or just straight up attention wh0ring. You need a certain type of social acuity to overcome such stigma and skepticism. If the bio or the communication doesn't convey some clue or explanation as to why such a quality man is seeking women online, women will bail out, often with the slightest provocation.
I'll bet anything that if you rewrite "Chad's" profile to convey his desire to find "a beautiful, quality woman, both inside and out...a woman who glows above all others in intelligence, trustworthiness and simplicity within the shallow cesspool of the singles night life", or some other really cheesy sh1t like that, that "Chad" will get more matches.
Give it a try just for sh1ts and giggles.