I guess the issue I see with this "analysis" is that it's way too categorical. I know I listed out labels as "Jerk" and "Thug" but from my experience there's really no explicit categories as if you are a regular guy, you should have a mixture of all of the major labels and you might be "Alpha" over here, "Jerk" over here and "Nice Guy" over here.
Brad in regards to your categories, I don't know man, I just haven't experienced things to that extreme. If I had to use labels (which I hate), here's the labels I would use and their definitions:
Thug - I defined him earlier. He's usually a loser or a bum, or he might have found success in his underground drug dealing bullshyt. But he's not stable, usually in and out of jail.
Jerk - I think this guy is more of a natural guy where he's cool to be around but he's blunt and outspoken, being blunt and outspoken is why people usually call him an "a.sshole". He usually has his shyt together but some of them don't.
Simp - This is the guy with this shyt together or at least has it together to some extent. He worships women, women can do no wrong, he's almost like a Male Feminist.
Average Joe - This guys might not have his shyt together, might be working class, but he just doesn't usually stand out that much. He sort of falls into the background. I wouldn't say he was boring, he could be boring, he just doesn't stand out.
Now, depending on the girl, ALL of these guys will get laid. If each of them developed a strategy to go out and consistently meet women, they could begin spinning plates and develop into their own pseudo-Player. Women will like each one of these guys for various different reasons, but as I said, I don't believe women actually love ANY guy anymore, so at the end of the day it's all just Entertainment to her and a Financial Resource...or if not a Financial Resource some other type of Entertainment that she's obtaining.
This notion that the "Nice Guy" is some guy that's afraid to go speak to women and afraid to approach women, I'm wondering how old this guy is that you guys are referring to? Is this a grown a.ss man or a little boy? And let's be honest here, who DOESN'T get a "little nervous" when just flat out approaching a chick in public? Some chicks (especially black ones) can be flat out rude and embarrass the hell out of you. To be honest, I don't even approach black chicks COLD like that in the street no more lol. I do most of my gaming online, it's much more convenient. These chicks are crazy out here man.
I tend to like to be the Anti-Hero type of guy more of the time, as being a "Black Conservative" always makes me the "bad person" most of the time in my dealings. There are women that are attracted to that because I'm outspoken and blunt, but there are also women that can't STAND my a.ss because of it lol.
Just like you got these Male Feminists and Simps out here that you guys might even label as being "Nice" because they kiss women's a.ss, put them up on mountain tops, etc. But there are women out there that LIKE that shyt and dudes get laid left and right over it. Women that are looking to get married and SCREW you over in Court, get WET over Male Feminists and Simps.
I just can NEVER do that shyt. I'm not selling my soul to get some a.ss, I do okay with the a.ss I get now and if it ever comes a day where I can't bring in a.ss off regular meets then fvck it...I have money to buy it. At the end of the day, when I add up the money I spend on date(s), I'm BUYING it anyway!