Deus ex Pianoforte said:
Eh, I disagree. "Pook" comes off completely arrogant and full of himself, completely crossing the line from confident to ****y. He geared the "advice" to make it seem as if his personal decisions are the only way to go, in an effort to seek validation for the last 6 months of his life spent in the gym.
It doesn't matter what men look like to women, period. You could pull some homeless dude off the street, spray some cologne on him to mask the odor of dried piss and shi.t...and if his game is top-shelf, he will be pulling dimes left and right at the bookstore or club or wherever the f.uck you drop him off. Try doing the same for a homeless chick and see how well her game gets guys. Or better yet, drop a non-famous Johnny Depp with no game look alike off at the same place and watch how many 9's and 10's he pulls by walking around staring at the floor and occasionally asking chicks what their signs are.
Pook is actually right. I went from 5'10 140 to 195 back in 99-2000. Then I went back down to 145. Now I'm at 160. Granted when I was 195 probably 35 of those pounds where fat, but with clothes on you couldn't tell. That's still 20 lb of muscle, which makes a HUGE difference. My face even filled out. It "puffed" up.
I don't know where you are at now, but try to LOSE 55 pounds (especially if you are under 200) and see how people treat you.
The weight gain made such a difference that it's like I stepped into a whole new world. I was still acting completely AFC, so every opportunity that came my way I blew. I had this chick in class totally giving me cheshire grins, being the AFC I brought my guitar to class and sang her a song. Needless to say the extra weight gain didn't override the chump behavior.
I remember another time I had this chick like staring at me like you would a cute puppy. And I was like "what the hell is she doing" at the time. I didn't even know that girls send those types of signals, that's the amazing difference that weight gain can give.
Another time I went over to this ok looking chicks place and she like called her good looking friend and was like "omg, i met this cool dude you got to meet him". Her friend came over and I nailed her that night. Yeah, I got lucky cuz I was still AFC.
Recalling those days I now realize chicks where giving me MANY MANY more opportunities with them. Remember I went from 140 to 195 then back to 145. Trust me, I know.
Pook is not saying that weight is the ONLY thing that matters, just that it has a very high probability of making a very big difference. Which reminds me, I got to go workout.