Dear #17...Oh dear,some of you guys are just missing the plot...I think in retrospect you will think of this lady as doing you a big favour,it was symbiotic...a smooth situation,you obviously broke the golden rule and got too emotionally involved and wanted more from it,but there is a use by date,relationships are like babies they evolve and grow changing as they do,often on broadly predictable paths,you can spin this out but never prevent it.Consider her your proving ground giving you more confidence to spin other plates,and be free to move on...so there was Daddy on the scene?very very common,I know single women still shagging their ex after 25 years,don't you think you should be better prepared?at the risk of seeming tedious Jophil has it right You guys have to be trained,"Spotting helpful Hubbies".. would seem to deserve a chapter on its own ,you just have to learn to detect the problem and take mild but assertive action,never blame Hubby,he is just following a biological urge.For lonely men these ladies are a gold mine you just cannot see.Think of it this way,you are shipwrecked alone and hungry,marooned on a Desert Island,well you have two choices,sit and grizzle about what a poor bugger you are and starve to death,or adapt,so learn to enjoy raw fish and coconuts until you see a sail on the horizon,perhaps I could extend the analogy by further suggesting that if you get too busy in this Hunter-Gatherer role you might miss the boat..As the papers down under digest the news that 25% of young males down here expect to marry Virgins,then many guys are going to go home to a cold slice of last nights Pizza in a lonely home..