Hey there Spang,
I don't believe in acting like a bad guy just to get girls.
I think that instead of going from
Nice guy >>>> A$$hat
You should go from
Nice guy >>>> Confident, daring guy
What I mean is this.
When you focus on achieving a certain outcome with a girl (i.e. getting her number) and you are fixed up this you sometimes sacrifice your ability to be edgy, a bit naughty and daring.
For instance, imagine you were a diplomat for your nation and your nation was in a rapidly detoriating situation with a nation much larger and powerful than your own. As a diplomat you are sent to speak with the leaders of the Super Power and if you upset them your country will face war, suffering and significant pain.
Coming into this meeting your attitude would be
- walking on proverbial egg shells
- very polite and absolutely not attempting any 'risky' jokes (paying someone out jokingly)
- nervous as all hell
- desperately trying not to offend the other person
Because you would be fixated on the outcome (i.e. not starting a war) you would lose the jokey, natural charm nature of your personality.
Sometimes guys adopt this attitude when talking to girls
They become so fixated on the outcome that they sacrifice this risk-taking part of their persona. The great thing is though you can drop this attitude because a negative outcome (rejection/no number) is completely insignificant compared to the example situation (War).
When you are talking to a girl and ask for her number you have absolutely nothing to lose
positive outcome = you get her number
negative outcome = your situation remains the same as before you approached her. You lose nothing but gain the experience of approaching a girl
Because you have nothing to lose you can be more risk aye (sorry not sure how to spell it)
My advice for you would be to
Become more risk aye and exciting in your conversations with girls
For example, In the past I felt it was inappropriate/rude to mention sexual things and make sexual references with a girl. Now, I try to be more cheeky and playful and incorporate sexual jokes and comments. These can be risque (about any taboo sexual thing or regular sex) and sometimes don't work out. But I keep doing it anyway. I feel that you want to get some emotional reaction from a girl and if you're being risque you can get a shock or embarrassed reaction.
I believe that
Women want guys who are willing to say risque things and who are daring and willing to take chances even though there is a very real possibility of failure
For me, I went through a lot of pain and soul searching from a particular girl and I felt that my mistake was just caring too much about her.
I found great comfort in "not really giving a sh!t about what girls think" This doesn't mean I didn't listen to them or acted rude. Instead, this means that I 'went there' I began to be unafraid to offend a girl, to make a joke at her expense and sometimes this pulled off and sometimes it didn't.
E.g.
Yesterday I was talking to a girl
So she had mentioned she was in group 3
A few minutes in the conversation later
...
Her: Well only great looking people are in group X
Me: Wait, hold on a minute so why are you in group X then? (said with a mischevious grin)
Her: Oh no you didn't. (a reaction of a bit of a smile/shock/mock offended)
i guess my biggest problem is i dont know WHAT to say. i dont approach them to discuss particle physics or anything like that. im an engineering student so im more into that kind of stuff. i just ask them about themselves or make an observation to talk about.
ill give an example....for about the last month ive been hanging out in coffee shops and the library, just trying to put myself in a position to meet them. i was in starbucks one day and this attractive girl was sitting across from me. i worked up the courage and talked to her. she was reading a book on medical stuff and i asked her about it. she was in college like me and we got to talking about our fields. then asked about her life and she asked about mine some. it went ok and we talked for a good 30 minutes(logical conversation). she just seemed uncomfortable in my presence or something. she didnt seem interested in me at all. i didnt ask for her number because of that, so i asked if she would be back here again any next week and she said i dont know youll see me around, im in here all the time. (but earlier she said she hardly comes in there.)
I would definitely advocate working on producing an emotional response. As guys it's sometimes easy to become to logical (something I can do).
Analysing your interaction with that girl here are my notes
+ I like that you've approached her
- You made 'classic' small chat with her. She has conversations about what she's studying at college with tons of people. First or second at parties is often "So what are you studying?". You want to be 'daring, different, fun' and this well worn path isn't exciting.
O I would advise looking up 'active listening' and the skills involved so that when she is talking to you about her life you can show that you are listening and understand it the best.
- You talked about medical stuff which isn't particularly sexy. Unless she has a fetish for medical chat (which is a super long shot) this conversation won't turn her on. Think about the words we associate with medical things
Clinical
Professional
Logical
Scientific
and now compare these to attributes that women are said to find attractive
Exciting
Risk taking
Daring
Sexual
Emotional
These two list of words are almost complete opposites.
Instead of focussing on a logical exchange with a girl aim to "have fun, crack jokes, make bad jokes, confuse her, shock her and keep her on her toes"
I believe there is a great strength to be found in being prepared to look like a fool