@Backbreaker Hey, glad you're a fan of my stuff! Allow me to respond to your response to my post on this particular wall...
For starters, I don't know if you got the chance to read OP's original posting about this girl and the whole story - if you have, great; if not, here's the link to it:
http://www.sosuave.net/forum/showthread.php?t=199338
In summary, he met this girl at a college party; he made a date with her and she flaked twice (the second time being when her ex-BF showed up at her house and she cancelled while he was outside waiting for her); then wanted to make it up to him by having a date at his apartment that ended in sex.
Now, I understand about wanting romance and all... but romance is something that's EARNED over a period of dates. It's not something you just give out freely to every girl you take out right away; its something given to a woman as a result of her proving she's worthy of said attention.
Technically, these two haven't been on what could be considered a "real" date yet. She came over, they fvcked, she went home. Now, what part of that says "romance?" What part of this interaction would suddenly make her worthy of a next-day phone call? Next-day phone calls are made to girls who have proven themselves worthy of being cared for or thought about in that way; so far, she has 2 strikes against her record (i.e. two flake dates) and one sex outing that may or may not have been either a "revenge against ex-bf" screwing or a "I don't want to be seen as a bad person so I'll give him some" screwfest.
Now, the fact that she's saying she wants to see him again and left stuff at his place ARE good signs... but again, based off one lay after 2 bad experiences, calling her the next day isn't warranted. Remember, he GOT this chick after he layed off from talking to her a few days.
Guys think it's the end of the world if they don't call/text a girl immediately after everything they do with her. In the grand scheme of things, though, 2 to 3 days is NOT a long time. I dated a girl who called me at least once a day, and I NEVER called her unless I either missed her call or was planning a date.
During the times where I couldn't contact her for a few days in a row (i.e. on vacation, long shooting day on set, etc.), she was happy to hear from me even MORE when we reconnected. Which brings me to another reason why it's good to wait to call: to see if SHE herself is a psycho. I find that girls who insist on you calling them everyday tend to be the ones that are jealous, nosy, and are always questioning/second-guessing what their man was doing when she wasn't around.
I don't need a girl getting all nutso on me 'cause I couldn't contact her when she wanted me to - real talk, I once dated a girl who got mad at me 'cause my phone was off and she thought I was cheating. In actuality, I was in court all day waiting to testify against someone who had robbed my apartment. When I cut my phone back on during a break, I had a litany of text messages and voice mails of her crying/yelling/asking me to "be a man" and admit I was cheating on her. And I'm sitting there like, "really?!? All because I didn't call you for 6 hours straight??"
Anyway... in answer to the rest of your stuff: again, my opinion on the matter is based on my experiences. However, what I have found is that the more patient a guy is, the better his results.
Yes, a guy could try to call a girl the next day; but, in agreeing with your logic, much in the same way that a girl who likes him shouldn't get mad at him for calling the next day, that same girl should also not be mad at him if he waited a couple of days to call. And if she DOES get mad about it, it means that, on some level, she's controlling and mad that she's not currently the one in control of the situation.
How does she not know that he had other, more important things to do besides call her? Suppose they hooked up, and then the very next day one of his parents died? Or he got into an accident? Is he supposed to call her from the hospital that same day and be like "oh, before I go into surgery, I need to call this girl I went on a date with yesterday so she won't think I'm playing games??"
Of course not! And that's the point: a sane girl will be EAGER to get his call, but won't chastise him for not calling right away. It's one of the best sanity tests a guy can actually pull on a girl.
As for the whole "no games after sex" talk: eh, not true. Because, again, once you've had sex the girl may THINK she knows you're interested... but she doesn't know WHAT you're interested in (her, the sex, the ego rush it gave you, etc.) or at what level your interest is (high enough to call her, low enough to ignore her but hit her up for the occasional screwing)...
And, not every girl has sex for reasons that are pure. Oftentimes guys think that just because a girl agreed to bang us means we suddenly have her at our beck and call. Not true. Some sex because they're bored; or getting over someone; or wanted another notch on their purse strap; or felt ugly and needed someone fawning over them... I could go on, but the point is until you've been with them for a while, you don't REALLY know what, if any, game is being played.
I DO agree with your last statement on the subject, though: "girls aren't turned off by the call, they are turned off by the behavior that comes with the call." While I believe calling too soon can be part of this effect, I also believe that the reason these phone calls suck is because the conversation feels forced. They're calls being made by guys who feel they have to make them out of obligation, but really have nothing to say.
I guess my thing is, I don't like making calls for no reason. So, if I bang a girl, unless I'm planning on asking her out somewhere (or to come over again), I don't feel the need to make a call right away. Nor do I feel the need to have to make up a conversation, thinking it's going to build up their interest. I prefer building up their interest by not contacting them and letting them think about how good of a time they had the last time we WERE in contact together, thus allowing them to convince themselves that I'm worth seeing again. It's not everyone's method, but so far it's worked very, very well for me