Something I just learned about being the "nice guy"

TakenDirectly

Don Juan
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
54
Reaction score
2
Got hit pretty hard today by a fact. Too all the nice guys:

WOMEN DO NOT FEEL COMFORTABLE AROUND YOU

I was basically a nice guy around this one girl. So then I guess I get this sort of oneitis and I'm able to twist a conversation with her to see what she thought of me. Truth is she felt I was nice (probably even attractive), BUT that if she and I ever hooked up she would feel "shy". The way I see it, I reached a point to where she wouldn't feel like she could be herself. She would probably feel she would have to impress me instead of ATTRACT ME (this is my thought on it at least). Never really read the whole "nice guy" in that way, but basically I found out that a nice guy is someone that a girl cannot feel herself around. Even if you are suave and sexy but you become nice then she will push you towards the friendship zone. Feel like **** now, but I'm going to run my ass off until I can't feel feelings anymore. Just something I feel should be emphasized on.
 

ItsOnNow

Master Don Juan
Joined
Dec 16, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
2
Location
a house
So what? show no feelings at all? Just be what,go with the flow and what happens happens? this is where I am confused,what about true feelings of love and whathaveyou?
 

TakenDirectly

Don Juan
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
54
Reaction score
2
Love isn't something you should feel or express when you first meet someone. If you honestly believe you are in love after the 1st day, month, hour of meeting a girl then you're insane. I guess the process of attraction is more of a game that just has rules, requires strategy and some god given talent can help you go a long way. If it were as easy as saying "hey I like you" to just get the girl then there wouldn't be any single people. There is obviously a process to gain attraction and to keep it. Love is just something that a couple has when they can naturally and automatically attract each other without knowing it. I guess you could call that passion (?).
 

spanky

Senior Don Juan
Joined
Jun 30, 2003
Messages
282
Reaction score
1
TakenDirectly said:
Got hit pretty hard today by a fact. Too all the nice guys:

WOMEN DO NOT FEEL COMFORTABLE AROUND YOU

I was basically a nice guy around this one girl. So then I guess I get this sort of oneitis and I'm able to twist a conversation with her to see what she thought of me. Truth is she felt I was nice (probably even attractive), BUT that if she and I ever hooked up she would feel "shy". The way I see it, I reached a point to where she wouldn't feel like she could be herself. She would probably feel she would have to impress me instead of ATTRACT ME (this is my thought on it at least). Never really read the whole "nice guy" in that way, but basically I found out that a nice guy is someone that a girl cannot feel herself around. Even if you are suave and sexy but you become nice then she will push you towards the friendship zone. Feel like **** now, but I'm going to run my ass off until I can't feel feelings anymore. Just something I feel should be emphasized on.

You know what, I think attraction is so dynamic that you just can't blame being a nice guy on it all. So many things go into being attractive that you shouldn't stress over if you are being an ass enough or not. Nice guys score all of the time, man.


You can be a good person but if you are a door mat, people will not respect you and walk all over you. If you don't have any ballz then don't expect to score much.


I can tell you this, I used to be an azz in my relationship. Not because I was trying to but just because I really wasn't into my GFs much. I just wanted sex and a date when I wanted one but didn't want someone up under me all of the time. That was until I had met a great woman who loved the hell out of me and I realized that I was just being immature in my relationships. We broke up after years of dating because she finally gave up on ever winning my affection. I missed her a lot and learned a lot from her. When I tried to get her back, it was too late, I found out she was married. When I found this out, it was such a low point in my life and that initially is what drove me to this site.

I then became just as nice as she was to me to other chics I dated afterwards thinking I was using what I had learned from her in our relationship. These other women were really into me and genuinely were heartbroken when I dumped them. I realized that I was really treating these women so well in order for them to fall hard for me. I wanted them to think I was their knight in shining armor and then snatching every thing away from them all of a sudden. I sent them flowers, opened doors, complemented them (even when they were not nearly as sexy or drop dead gorgeous as I told them they were) etc.s... all what you guys call "AFC" stuff. I was subconsciously getting vengeance on women for me losing the only woman I had ever fallen in love with. I kind of felt guilty about it after I realized what I was doing.

I have now re-kindled a relationship with someone from my past that I broke up with because I was just an immature azz. I feel that she is the woman for me now and I will continue to treat her well and plan to be with her for a very long time.

When I reflect on why I was doing well with avoiding the friend zone despite treating women well, I believe it was a few things:


1. I took no BS! If a chic disrespected me, talk to me in a disrespectful tone, or didn't treat me like I felt like I deserved, I walked away without hesitation. They always got upset that I would leave their house or be ready to drop them off in certain situation and it changed their behavior.


2. I sold them dreams: I made them believe that they would live a great life being with me. I made them believe that they would attend the greatest social functions, take the greatest trips, be treated like a queen and blah blah blah. I indirectly made them believe that they wouldn't get this anywhere else or that these dreams would be so hard to achieve with anyone else.


3. I kept my personal and professional life together to show them I had dreams and goals and that I was going to achieve them all. I showed stability.


I think different things work for different people and this is basically what worked for me. I think you can be a nice guy and women still go crazy over you but you can't be a wimp or loser or you simply will just be punked and... lose.
 

TakenDirectly

Don Juan
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
54
Reaction score
2
That's what makes me wonder though. See the nice guy is considered a nice guy or doormat by the girl and this could be through ANY casual nice guy action. Even helping them with something heavy can just be WAY too much of a nice thing for them. From what I learned in this site, learning to do the right thing is done mostly through guaging their reaction. When a nice guy does something nice for a girl then the girl almost always seems to give a great reaction. The important part is what does the girl think afterwards of the guy. Since the nice guy sees a girl liking these nice guy actions then he will consider to do them more often. Fact is they can't read what this girl is REALLY thinking and they end up going overboard.

Weird thing is I never let anyone talk down to me or insult me. Sure as hell if a girl got in my face I'd make sure she's never do it again. It's just and upsetting thing to hear that I can even be attractive to her, but she feels that I'm just probably too much of a good guy to be with. IMO the nice guy isn't always the guy that girls see as a "friend" or "brother". In fact they can be attracted to them, but just feel like something is blocking them from going further with them.
 

You essentially upped your VALUE in her eyes by showing her that, if she wants you, she has to at times do things that you like to do. You are SOMETHING after all. You are NOT FREE. If she wants to hang with you, it's going to cost her something — time, effort, money.

Quote taken from The SoSuave Guide to Women and Dating, which you can read for FREE.

swifTy

Don Juan
Joined
Aug 16, 2007
Messages
149
Reaction score
2
WOMEN DO NOT FEEL COMFORTABLE AROUND YOU

they feel this bcoz they're like, well why is this guy doin all this nice stuff for me and being all nice to me. he must like me. oh no, i dont like him. oh crap. oh crap. i feel bad now. and he's so nice. what am i gonna do? i feel uncomfortable.

and in the end they just have to run away. theres nothin else they can do. they dont want to lead you on. and they can't be all nice nice back.

you'll find tho that if the girl fancies you and your being nice to her she will love it. she will feel like a princess. she'll probably tell all her gf's that. OMG he is such a catch, he treats me like a princess. i love him. omg.

The thing is; before you get to that stage.. She'll probably still be a bit suspicious bcoz of all the other guys that acted nice to her and were douches but once she sees that your the real deal your good to go.

smile around the one you like. be nice to the one you like. see if she likes you back. thats the key. hold respect for yourself and she'll hold respect for you. easy.
 

Poonani Maker

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
4,407
Reaction score
929
Well, when I want to put a gal off because I'm not really attracted to her, I'll be nice to her. And they know that there's this "other" side to me that I'm not showin em, and in a sense, that show n' tell hiding the prize makes them all the more drawn to me. When I make intentional niceness to ward them off, it doesn't work because they know I'm hiding how sexual I Really am. Happened today, I'm afraid. These two chicks, I think, both want me at the same time. One's ugly with a hook-nose, the other's hot with very fine tits. I've known the hot one off and on for almost two years. The hook-nosed one is new to me as of early this year.

Today, I said some off-the-wall **** - all the AFC weakness I showed - for instance, talking about some dude I know who gets all the women wherever he goes. I was going on and on about this dude like he was some god, NEVER talking about myself to them. My past was really never in the conversation, because that's how I wanted it - them not knowing nothing but bits and pieces of me.

It backfired. I left, I think, them wanting me more. I will see them next week. The fine one was trying to get me to ask her questions about herself, but I never fell for the bait.

We'll see what happens next week. Maybe they'll turn on me, forming the picture of me I want, of me being a loser. I really can't handle these chicks right now is why. I'm kinda serious with a gal I'm seeing tomorrow. Plus, these chicks know people who work with me and I just don't know if business and pleasure is a good thing, no matter how whory they appear to be. Maybe in a week I'll have a different change in plan for them, especially after seeing those breasts - she wanted me to see - when she bent over today, God I was salivating like a dog and she's caught me looking at her friend bending over so she knows my nature is to look when they ain't lookin.
 

swifTy

Don Juan
Joined
Aug 16, 2007
Messages
149
Reaction score
2
Well, when I want to put a gal off because I'm not really attracted to her, I'll be nice to her
you'll confuse her if you do that. she might interpret it as you leading her on. if you dont like a girl and want to communicate that then dont talk to her. if you do anything else then your as bad as an AW. your basically showing off.
 

TakenDirectly

Don Juan
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
54
Reaction score
2
Yeah I guess you're right. This was a girl at work so seeing her so much pretty much gave me the oneitis. Still sucks though. I really thought I had it, but I guess I blew it.
 

Bible_Belt

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
17,104
Reaction score
5,735
Age
48
Location
midwestern cow field 40
I remember listening to a couple girls from school talk about their weekend's dates every Monday. One would ask how it went and the other would say, "well...he was really nice..." and then the other girl would nod knowingly. Nothing more needed to be said; both girls knew that guy was out of the picture and would not be seeing her again.
 

Never try to read a woman's mind. It is a scary place. Ignore her confusing signals and mixed messages. Assume she is interested in you and act accordingly.

Quote taken from The SoSuave Guide to Women and Dating, which you can read for FREE.

Francisco d'Anconia

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jul 10, 2003
Messages
15,502
Reaction score
63
Location
Galt's Gulch
Bible_Belt said:
I remember listening to a couple girls from school talk about their weekend's dates every Monday. One would ask how it went and the other would say, "well...he was really nice..." and then the other girl would nod knowingly. Nothing more needed to be said; both girls knew that guy was out of the picture and would not be seeing her again.
I'd guess this happens a least 8 out of 10 times with women. This is why "going with the flow and seeing what happens" is the death knell for most (nice) guys. If guys would actually think about the persona they'd want to convey to a woman, they'd have a chance of being described as:
  • Funny
  • Charismatic
  • Adventurous
  • Insightful
  • Engaging
  • Alluring
  • etc...
As opposed to being described as "Oh, he was nice..." :yawn:YAWWWWNNNNNN!!!!!! Well, at least she got a free dinner... :rolleyes:
 

TakenDirectly

Don Juan
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
54
Reaction score
2
I had a ****y funny thing going on though. We talked **** a lot of the time, but I wanted to keep a balance by compliments and maybe some assistance. To tell you the truth though I think I know what I didn't do. I wasn't sexual enough. IMO this girl needed to be grabbed and held and rubbed in order to think and feel like I was that type of guy. While the girl is cute, she's nothing special and I just gotta get over it.
 
Top