LOL regarding the Amish. Interestingly, though, I was in Amish country a couple years ago and I noticed there were some extraordinarily attractive young fillies out there.
To each his own. I have really grown to hate large amounts of makeup. There are two ways to use makeup... One is as a slight and tasteful seasoning to enhance the "dish", and the other is a cosmetic face dump that hides what's really there. For me, these women are literally creating an illusion which triggers men to react.
I do like a little subtle makeup. I just don't like the full paint job. I find it fake and manipulative. I'm fortunate to have a girl who has that natural beauty I love. She doesn't need makeup at all, even at her age. She definitely won the genetic lottery, to my benefit. For me, there's nothing like a fresh, smiling female face that is natural and without pretense. It's easy for me to overlook minor flaws because I value naturalness over cover-up. That's just my preference. When I see an artificially manufactured woman, I see massive problems behind the facade. That speaks louder to me than the exterior paint job.