first of all, hot is presepctiive. For you to say she is not 'hot' because she doesn't meet your standards is not fair.
I happen to be attractive to rail-thin women. My friends don't have the same taste as I do, ,but it's my taste... I really don't give a damn what they think because they are not the ones who have to **** her.
pathethic guys, ,just plain pathethic.
I mean, no one asked you was she a tad bit overweight. Sure. NO denying it. I mean, she isn't fat by any means, but I don't date girls that have a bigger waist then me.
However, it's HIS girlfriend that HE is laying the pipe to (hopefully). He didn't ask how she LOOKED, he asked how they looked together.