I have to be honest; I though this message was stupid when I first read it, but as any other technique, I decided to test it before ditching it and here are the responses. I actually nailed it in similar website.
The message I sent:
"Subject: Congratu-friggin'-lations!
Yours is THE single GREATEST written profile in the HISTORY of [website]!
I swear I'm going to print it out and save it on my fridge....FOREVER! You adorable lil nerd you! =] "
I also added I'm a Celtics fan. I'm in LA and everyone likes the Celtics, but I'm from Boston and I'm green-jersey all day, haha. I think I should get rid of the smiley face in the message though, comments?
Responses and images of the targets:
http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i202/Robyn923b/thm_phpgg4Tsp.jpg
Her: "ok, lmaoo LAKERS
"
Me:You're killing me...No "about me", no traits or comments about who you are. How am I supposed to qualify you and see if I'm interested, kiddo?!
Her:"Lmfaoo I don't know !!! I hate celtics
" (She actually negged ME and then she gave me a smile, ahah).
Next girl:
http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i202/Robyn923b/thm_phpf40GY7.jpg
Her: "Hah uhm thank you?
"
Next girl:
http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i202/Robyn923b/thm_php84G2BR.jpg
Her: "hahaha thanks. glad you enjoyed it"
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And then there's this other girl who I haven't messaged, but keeps checking out my profile. I'm thinking about getting more info from their profiles and then sending thema more genuine, personalized message while still busting their balls off