You're right, Reese is not that hot, atleast not for Hollywood. If she were out at some local bar, she would barely even stand out. I don't like her pointy shaped chin and her face reminds me of a gremblin from that movie.
This girl reminds me of Reese, but is alot better looking:
http://www.imdb.com/gallery/hh/0176882/iid_918248.jpg.html?path=pgallery&path_key=Cook, A.J.&seq=8
All of these replies just reiterate that the whole "beauty is in the eye of the beholder" is true, but only to an small extent.
No guy on this planet would say she (Miss America) is unattractive or only average looking. The only differences in taste is if she is attractive or super attractive.
My friends and I were at the bar last night and we all noticed who the hot girls were and did not disagree on who was hot or not.